The purpose of this essay is to compare the story of Er in Plato's Republic's tenth book with the concept of antarābhava in the Vedic World and the ancient schools of Buddhism. First, the story of Er, a warrior who was believed to have died in battle and returned to life shortly before his body was burnt on the pyre, will be told. Er describes the vision he had before returning to life: he saw the actions and fate of the disembodied souls in the state and stage before their reincarnation. Next, the Indian doctrine of antarābhava, the intermediate state between death and rebirth, according to the Vedic religion and ancient schools of Buddhism, will be discussed. Finally, we will say a few concluding words to make a historical-religious comparison between the two in order to better understand both these doctrines and visions of the afterlife.
Annas, J. (1982). Plato's Myths of Judgement. Phronesis, 27(2): 119–143.
Bergren, Th.A. (2017). Plato’s ‘Myth of Er’ and Ezekiel’s ‘Throne Vision’: A Common Paradigm? Numen, 64: 153–182.
Brisson, L. (1982). Platon les mots et les mythes. Maspero, Paris.
Collobert, C. et al. (2012). Plato and Myth. Studies on the Use and Status of Platonic Myths. Brill, Leiden–Boston.
Franke, Th. (2021). Platonische Mythen: Was sie sind und was sie nicht sind – Von A wie Atlantis bis Z wie Zamolxis. BoD Books on Demand, Norderstedt.
Frutiger, P. (1930). Les mythes de Platon. Étude philosophique et littéraire. Alcan, Paris.
Halliwell, St. (2007). The Life-and-Death Journey of the Soul: Interpreting the Myth of Er. In: Ferrari, G.R.F. (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Plato's Republic. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp. 445–473.
Johnson, R.R. (1999). Does Plato’s ‘Myth of Er’ Contribute to the Argument of the ‘Republic’? Philosophy & Rhetoric, 32: 1–13.
Malabou, C. (2017). Odysseus’ Changed Soul: A Contemporary Reading of the Myth of Er. In: Greenstine, A.J. – Johnson, R.J. (eds.), Contemporary Encounters with Ancient Metaphysics. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh, pp. 30–46.
Murray, P (1999). What is a Mythos for Plato? In: Buxton, R. (ed.), From Myth to Reason: Studies in the Development of Greek Thought. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 251–262.
Rowe, Ch.J. (1999). Myth, History and Dialectic in Plato's Republic and Timaeus-Critias. In: Buxton, R. (ed.), From Myth to Reason: Studies in the Development of Greek Thought. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 263–278.
Schils, G. (1993). Plato’s Myth of Er : The Light and the Spindle. L’Antiquité Classique, 62: 101–114.
Segal, R.A. (2015). Myth : A Very Short Introduction. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Shorey, P. (trans.) (1969). Plato in Twelve Volumes. Vols. 5 & 6: Republic. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press – London: William Heinemann Ltd.
Thayer, H.S. (1988). The Myth of Er. History of Philosophy Quarterly, 5: 369–384.
Wilberding, J. (2013). The Myth of Er and the Problem of Constitutive Luck. In: Sheppard A.D.R. (ed.), Ancient approaches to Plato’s Republic. Institute of Classical Studies, University of London, pp. 87–105.
Cuevas, B.J. (1996). Predecessors and Prototypes: Towards A Conceptual History of the Buddhist Antarābhava. Numen, 43: 263–302.
Cuevas, B.J. (2003). The Hidden History of The Tibetan Book of the Dead. New York: Oxford University Press.
Höchsmann, H. (2016). Cosmology, psyche and ātman in the Timaeus, the Ṛgveda and the Upaniṣads. In Seaford, R. (ed.), Universe and Inner Self in Early Indian and Early Greek Thought. Edinburgh University Press, pp. 71–86.
Kloppenborg, R. (1974). The Paccekabuddha: A Buddhist Ascetic. Brill, Leiden.
Kritzer, R. (1997). Antarābhava in the Vibhasa. Maranatha’. Bulletin of the Christian Culture Research Institute, 5: 91(11)–69(33).
Kritzer, R. (2000). Rupa and the Antarābhava. Journal of Indian Philosophy, 28: 235–272.
La Vallee Poussin, L. de (ed.) (1988–1990). Abhidharmakosabhasyam. English translation by Pruden, L. M. Asian Humanities Press, Berkeley.
Langer, R. (2007). Buddhist rituals of death and rebirth. Contemporary Sri Lankan practice and its origins. Routledge, London.
Lin, Q. (2012). The antarābhava dispute among Abhidharma traditions and the list of anāgāmins. Journal of the International Association of Buddhist Studies, 34(1–2): 149–186.
Lincoln, B. (1986). Cosmos, and Society: Indo-European Themes of Creation and Destruction. Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
Mejor, M. (2008). Vasubandhu’s Abhidharmakosa in Non-Buddhist Philosophical Treatises. In: Gombrich, R.F. – Scherrer-Schaub, C. (eds.), Buddhist Studies: Papers of the 12th World Sanskrit Conference. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi, pp. 119–150.
Nanda, A. (2019). The Concept of Intermediate Existence in the Early Buddhist Theory of rebirth. Asian Philosophy, 29(2): 144–159.
Salvati, A. (2020). Santo e santità nel buddhismo. Aspetti morfologici e modelli di santità in Santo e Santità. Roma, Grecia, Tarda Antichità, Buddhismo, Lithos, pp. 137–157.
Shoryu, K. (2003). Some cases of doctrinal proofs in the Abhidharmakośabhāṣya. Journal of Indian Philosophy, 31: 105–120.
Smith, B.K. (1989). Reflections on Resemblance, Ritual, and Religion. Oxford University Press, New York.
Wayman, A. (1974). The Intermediate-State Dispute in Buddhism. In: Cousins, L. – Kunst, A. – Norman, K.R. (eds.), Buddhist Studies in Honour of I. B. Horner. D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht–Boston, pp. 227–239.