View More View Less
  • 1 Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway
Restricted access

This article is an empirical study of two science and health policy controversies — “to screen or not to screen” with ultrasound in pregnancy and with mammography for breast cancer. In each case, conflicting experimental results have been published. Which of the results have been accepted within the medical science community? The article is also a theoretical and methodological study of three views of science — an institutional view, an interests view, and a semiotic view. How might each approach scientific publications as evidence? Could they be eclectically combined in a more complex view of science discourse?

  • Alfonsi, P. Cutrupi, V. 1992 Natural History of Breast Cancer Lancet 339 810.

  • Andersson, I Aspegren, K. Janzon, L. Landberg, T. Lindholm, K. Linell, F. Ljungberg, O. Ranstam, J. SigfÚsson, B. 1988 Mammographic screening and mortality from breast cancer: The Malmö mammographic screening trial British Medical Journal 297 943948.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Backe, B. 1986 Ultralydundersøkelser i Norge. Dagens utbredelse Backe, B. Buhaug, H. (eds.) Konsensuskonferansen 27–29/8–1986, Bruk av ultralyd i svangerskapet NIS Trondheim 3537.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Backe, B. 1989 Hvorfor en konsensuskonferanse om mammografiscreening? Backe, B. (eds.) Konsensuskonferansen om Mammografiscreening, 8.–10, februar 1989 NIS Trondheim 1921.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Backe, B. Buhaug, H. 1986 Konsensuskonferansen 27–29/8–1986. Bruk av Ultralyd i Svangerskap NIS Trondheim.

  • Backe, B. Jacobsen, G. Bakketeig, L.S. BergsiØ, P. 1987 Distribution and practice of diagnostic ultrasound in Norwegian obstetric institutions Tidsskrift for Den norske Lœgeforening 5 471473.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Bakketeig, L.S. Jacobsen, G. Brodtkorb, C.J. Eriksen, B.C. Eik-Nes, S.H. Ulstein, M.K. Balstad, P. Jorgensen, N.P. 1984 Randomised controlled trial of ultrasonographic screening in pregnancy Lancet 8396 207211.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Bennett, M.J. Little, G. Dewhurst, J. Chamberlain, G. 1982 Predictive Value of Ultrasound Measurements in Early Pregnancy: A Randomised Controlled Trial British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 89 338341.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Breart, G. Ringa, V. 1990 Routine or selective ultrasound scanning Bailièrres Clinical Obstetrics and Gynaecology 4 4563.

  • Bodewitz, H. J. Buurma, H. De Vries, G. H. 1987 Regulatory science and the social management of trust in medicine Buker, W. E. Hughes, T. P. Pinch, T. (eds.) The Social Construction of Technological Systems MIT Press Cambridge, MA 243259.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Cartwright, R.A. McKinney, P.A. Hopton, P.A. Birch, J.M. Hartley, A.L. Mann, J.R. Waterhouse, J.A.H. Johnston, H.E. Draper, G.J. Stiller, C. 1984 Ultrasound examinations in pregnancy and childhood cancer Lancet 8410 9991000.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Chalmers, I. 1990 Underreporting research is scientific misconduct Journal of the American Medical Association 263 1406.

  • Cochrane, A.L. (1972), Effectiveness and Efficiency, Random Reflections on Health Services, The Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust.

  • Collins, H. M. 1985 Changing Order. Replication and Induction in Scientific Practice University of Chicago Press Chicago and London.

  • Collins, H. M. Pinch, T. J. 1982 Frames of Meaning: the Social Construction of Extraordinary Science Routledge London.

  • Cozzens, S. E. 1990 Editorial in Science Technology, & Human Values 15 58.

  • Deber, R.B. 1992 Translating technology assessment into policy. Conceptual issues and tough choices International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 8 131137.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • DeCrespigny, L. Ch. , Warren, P., Buttery, B. (1989), Should all pregnant women be offered an ultrasound examination?, The Medical Journal of Australia, 151 (December 4/18), 614.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Eik-Nes, S.H. Økland, O. Aure, J.C. Ulstein, M. 1984 Ultrasound screening in pregnancy: A randomized controlled trial, Letter Lancet 8390 1347.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Ewigman, B.G. 1989 An opposing view The Journal of Family Practice 29 663.

  • Ewigman, B.G., J.P. Crane, F.D. Frigoletto, M.L. LeFevre, R.P. Bain, D. McNellisthe RADIUS study group 1993 Effect of prenatal ultrasound screening on perinatal outcome New England Journal of Medicine 329 12 821827.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Ewigman, B. LeFevre, M. Hesser, J. 1990 A randomized trial of routine prenatal ultrasound Obstetrics and Gynecology 76 189194.

  • Feinglass, J. Salmon, J. W. 1990 Corporatization of medicine: The use of medical management information systems to increase the clinical productivity of physicians International Journal of Health Services 20 233252.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Feinstein, A.R. 1994 Clinical judgment revisited: The distraction of quantitative models Annals of Internal Medicine 120 799805.

  • Frisell, J. Eklund, G. Hellstrom, L. Lindbrink, E. Rutqvist, L.E. Somell, A 1991 Randomized study of mammography screening — Preliminary report on mortality in the Stockholm Trial Breast Cancer Research and Treatment 18 4956.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Goldkrand, J.W. Benjamin, D.S. Cantor, D.M. 1986 Role of ultrasound in obstetric management Journal of Clinical Ultrasound 14 589594.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Hiddinga, A. Blume, S. S. 1992 Technology, science, and obstetric practice: The origins and transformation of cephalopelvimetry Science, Technology, & Human Values 17 154179.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Holzgreve, W. 1990 Sonographic screening for anatomic defects Seminars in Perinatology 14 504513.

  • International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care (1987) 3: 399.

  • Jacoby, I. 1985 The consensus development program of the National Institutes of Health. Current practices and historical perspectives International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 1 420432.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Latour, B. 1987 Science in Action. How to Follow Scientists and Engineers Through Society Open University Press Milton Keynes.

  • Latour, B. Woolgar, S. 1979 Laboratory Life. The Social Construction of Scientific Facts SAGE London and Beverly Hills.

  • Lemire, R.J. 1988 Neural tube defects Journal of the American Medical Association 259 559.

  • Li, T.C.M. Greenes, R.A. Weisberg, M. Millan, D. Flatley, M. Goldman, L. 1988 Data assessing the usefulness of screening obstetrical ultrasonography for detecting fetal and placental abnormalities in uncomplicated pregnancy Medical Decision Making 8 4854.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • MacKenzie, D. Barnes, B. 1979 Scientific judgment: The biometry-mendelism controversy Barnes, B Shapin, R. (eds.) Natural Order. Historical Studies of Scientific Culture Sage Beverley Hills/London 191210.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • McGlynn, E.A. Kosecoff, J. Brook, R.H. 1990 Format and conduct of consensus development conferences. Multination comparison International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 6 450469.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • McKinlay, J.B. 1981 From ‘Promising Report' to 'standard Procedure': Seven stages in the career of a medical innovation Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly/Health and Society 59 374411.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Merton, R. K. 1957 Social Theory and Social Structure Free Press New York.

  • Miller, A.B. Baines, C.J. To, T. Wall, C. 1992 Canadian national breast screening study. 1. Breastcancer detection and death rates among women aged 40 to 49 years Canadian Medical Association Journal 147 14591476.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Miller, A.B. Baines, C.J. To, T. Wall, C. 1992 Canadian national breast screening study. 2. Breastcancer detection and death rates among women aged 50 to 59 years Canadian Medical Association Journal 147 14771488.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Ministry Of Health And Social Affairs And Norwegian Institute Of Hospital Research 1987 Ultrasound in pregnancy: Consensus statement 1986 International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 3 463470.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Moskowitz, M. 1985 Do the results of the Swedish trial, the Dutch case control study, and the Cincinnati breast cancer detection demonstration project tell us anything of importance about the natural history of breast cancer? Gordenne, Colin (eds.) Evaluation du risque de cancer mammaire Pierre Mardaga Brussels 119120.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Myers, G. 1990 Writing Biology: Texts in the Social Construction of Scientific Knowledge University of Wisconsin Press Madison.

  • Nattinger, A.B. Goodwin, J.S. 1992 Screening mammography for older women. A case of mixed messages Archives of Internal Medicine 152 922925.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Neilson, J.P. Munjanja, S.P. Whitfield, C.R. 1984 Screening for small for dates fetuses: A controlled trial British Medical Journal 289 11791182.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Norges Offentlige Utredninger (NOU) (1984) 17: Perinatal omsorg i Norge.

  • Norges Offentlige Utredninger (NOU) (1987) 7: Mammografiscreening i Norge.

  • Noseworthy J.H. , Ebers, G.C., Vandervoort, M.K., Farquhar, R.E., Yetisir, E., Roberts, R. (1994), The impact of blinding on the results of a randomized, placebo-controlled multiple sclerosis clinical trial, Neurology, 1620.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Perry, S. Kalberer, J.T. 1980 The NIH Consensus-Development Program and the Assessment of Health-Care Technologies The New England Journal of Medicine 303 169172.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Pinch, T. J. 1986 Confronting Nature: The Sociology of Solar-Neutrino Detection Reidel Dordrecht.

  • Poisson-Salomon, A.S. Breart, G. Maillard, F. Rumeau-Rouquette, C. 1987 Distribution of ultrasound examination during pregnancy in France between 1976 and 1981 International Journal of Epidemiology 16 234238.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Ramsey-Stewart, G. 1992 Mammography is fallible The Medical Journal of Australia 156 67.

  • Ravnskov, U. 1992 Frequency of citation and outcome of cholesterol lowering trials, Letter British Medical Journal 305 717.

  • Richards, E. 1991 Vitamin C and Cancer: Medicine of Politics Macmillan London.

  • Ringa, V. Blondel, B. Breart, G. 1989 Ultrasound in obstetrics: Do the published evaluative studies justify its routine use? International Journal of Epidemiology 18 489497.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Rosendahl, H. Kivinen, S. 1988 Routine ultrasound screening for early detection of small for gestational age fetuses Obstetrics and Gynecology 71 518521.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Saari-Kemppainen, A. Karjalainen, O. YlÖstalo, P. Heinonen, O.P. 1990 Ultrasound screening and perinatal mortality: controlled trial of systematic one-stage screening in pregnancy Lancet 336 387391.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Shapiro, S. 1977 Evidence on screening for breast cancer from a randomized trial Cancer 39 27722782.

  • Shapiro, S. Venet, W. Strax, P. Venet, L. 1988 Periodic screening for breast cancer: the Health Insurance Plan project and its sequelae 1963–1986 Johns Hopkins University Press Baltimore.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Shapiro, S. Venet, W. Strax, P. Venet, L. Roesner, R. 1982 Ten-to fourteen-year effect of screening on breast cancer mortality Journal of the National Cancer Institute 69 349355.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Shapiro, S., Venet, W., Strax, P., Venet, L., Roesner, R. (1985), Selection, follow-up and analysis in the Health Insurance Plan (HIP) study, Selection, follow-up and analysis in prospective studies: A workshop, National Cancer Institute Monography 67, pp. 6574.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Strax, P. 1980 Strategy (motivation) for detection of early breast cancer Cancer 27 15631568.

  • TabÁr, L. 1990 Control of breast cancer through screening mammography Radiology 174 655656.

  • TabÁr, L. Dean, P.B. 1989 The present state of screening for breast cancer Seminars in Surgical Oncology 5 94101.

  • TabÁr, L. Duffy, S.W. Krusemo, U.B. 1987 Detection method, tumor size and node metastases in breast cancers diagnosed during a trial of breast cancer screening European Journal of Cancer and Clinical Oncology 23 959962.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • TabÁr, L. Fagerberg, C.J.G. Day, N.E. Holmberg, L. 1987 What is the optimal interval between mammographic screening examinations: An analysis based on the latest results of the Swedish two-county breast cancer screening trial British Journal of Cancer 55 547551.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • TabÁr, L. Fagergerg, C.J.G. Duffy, S.W. Day, N.E. 1989 The Swedish two county trial of mammographic screening for breast cancer: recent results and calculation of benefit Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 43 107114.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • TabÁr, L. Fagerberg, C.J.G. Duffy, S.W. Day, N.E. Gad, A. GrÖntoft, O. 1992 Update of the Swedish two-county program of mammographic screening for breast cancer Radiological Clinics of North America 30 187210.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • TabÁr, L., Fagerberg, C.J.G., Gad, A., Baldetorp, L., Holmberg, L.H., GrÖntoft, O., Ljungquist, U., LundstrÖm, B., MÅnson, J.C., Eklund, G., Day, N.E., Pettersson, F. (1985), Reduction in mortality from breast cancer after screening with mammography, Lancet, 829832.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • TabÁr, L. Gad, A. Holmberg, L.H. Liungquist, U. Fagerberg, C.J.G. Baldetorp, L. GrÖntoft, O. LundstrÖm, B. MÅnson, J.C. Eklund, G. Day, N.E. Pettersson, F. 1985 Minskad mortalitet i bröstcancer genom hälsokontroll med mammografi Läkartidningen 82 15511554.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Thacker, S.B. 1985 Quality of controlled clinical trials. The case of imaging ultrasound in obstetrics: a review British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 92 437444.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • WaldenstrÖm U. , Axelsson, O., Nilsson, S., Eklund, G., Fall, O., Lindeberg, S., SjÖdin, Y. (1988), Effects of routine one-stage ultrasound screening in pregnancy: A randomised controlled trial, Lancet, 585588.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Walsh, S., Nichol, G., Penman, M., Tugwell, P., Moher, D. (1994), Assessing the quality of reports of randomized controlled trials used in systematic overviews, paper presented at the 10th Annual Meeting of the International Society for Tehcnology Assessment in Health Care, Baltimore: June 19–22.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Wright, C.J. 1986 Breast-cancer screening — A different look at the evidence Surgery 100 594598.

  • Zuckerman, H. 1988 The sociology of science Smelser, N. J. (eds.) Handbook of Sociology Sage Newbury Park/Beverly Hills/London/New Delhi 511574.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation

Manuscript submission: http://www.editorialmanager.com/scim/

  • Impact Factor (2019): 2.867
  • Scimago Journal Rank (2019): 1.210
  • SJR Hirsch-Index (2019): 106
  • SJR Quartile Score (2019): Q1 Computer Science Apllications
  • SJR Quartile Score (2019): Q1 Library and Information Sciences
  • SJR Quartile Score (2019): Q1 Social Sciences (miscellaneous)
  • Impact Factor (2018): 2.770
  • Scimago Journal Rank (2018): 1.113
  • SJR Hirsch-Index (2018): 95
  • SJR Quartile Score (2018): Q1 Library and Information Sciences
  • SJR Quartile Score (2018): Q1 Social Sciences (miscellaneous)

For subscription options, please visit the website of Springer

Scientometrics
Language English
Size B5
Year of
Foundation
1978
Volumes
per Year
4
Issues
per Year
12
Founder Akadémiai Kiadó
Founder's
Address
H-1117 Budapest, Hungary 1516 Budapest, PO Box 245.
Publisher Akadémiai Kiadó
Springer Nature Switzerland AG
Publisher's
Address
H-1117 Budapest, Hungary 1516 Budapest, PO Box 245.
CH-6330 Cham, Switzerland Gewerbestrasse 11.
Responsible
Publisher
Chief Executive Officer, Akadémiai Kiadó
ISSN 0138-9130 (Print)
ISSN 1588-2861 (Online)