Although patterns of facial preferences have been examined in many studies, the intra-individual variation in assessments of facial attractiveness has been addressed far less frequently. Here we investigated the stability of women's evaluations of real and digitally manipulated male faces at monthly and yearly intervals, and we sought determinants of the stability. The following results were obtained: (1) The stability of attractiveness assessments over a year was not lower than over a month. This suggests that between-session disparity is predominantly from factors fluctuating over time with no directional trends. (2) The breakdown of a relationship resulted in an increase in the preference for friendly looking faces. (3) The change of mood positively correlated with the change of preference for good-genes facial cues, but only in paired women. This suggests the influence of mood changes on women's readiness to cheat their long-term partner in order to “gain” good genes. (4) Women that were relatively open to casual sex manifested relatively high stability of preferences for sexy looking faces. (5) The mean between-session self-correlation of attractiveness assessments amounted to 0.78 (R2 = 61%), which is unexpectedly low given generally very efficient face processing in humans.
A. S. Attwood I. S. Penton-Voak M. R. Munafò 2009 Effects of acute nicotine administration on ratings of attractiveness of facial cues Nicotine and Tobacco Research 11 44 48.
T. C. M. Bakker 1993 Positive genetic correlation between female preference and preferred male ornament in sticklebacks Nature 363 255 257.
W. A. Becker 1984 Manual of Quantitative Genetics Academic Enterprises, Pullman Washington.
G. Blom 1958 Statistical Estimates and Transformed Beta-variables John Wiley & Sons, Inc. New York.
P. M. Bronstad R. Russell 2007 Beauty is in the ‘we’ of the beholder: Greater agreement on facial attractiveness among close relations Perception 36 1674 1681.
R. Brooks 1996 Copying and the repeatability of mate choice Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 39 323 329.
R. Brooks J. A. Endler 2001 Female guppies agree to differ: Phenotypic and genetic variation in mate-choice behavior and the consequences for sexual selection Evolution 55 1644 1655.
Bruce, V. & Young, A. W. (1998): In the Eye of the Beholder: The Science of Face Perception. Oxford University Press.
D. Burns 1999 The feeling good handbook William Morrow and Company New York.
D. M. Burt R. W. Kentridge J. M. M. Good D. I. Perrett B. P. Tiddeman L. G. Boothroyd 2007 Q-cgi: new techniques to assess variation in perception applied to facial attractiveness Proceedings of the Royal Society B 274 2779 2784.
D. M. Buss D. P. Schmitt 1993 Sexual strategies theory: An evolutionary perspective on human mating Psychological Review 100 204 232.
D. Buss 1999 Evolutionary Psychology: The New Science of the Mind Allyn & Bacon Boston.
M. R. Cunningham A. P. Barbee C. L. Pike 1990 What do women want? Facialmetric assessment of multiple motives in the perception of male facial physical attractiveness Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 59 61 72.
L. M. Debruine A. C. Little D. I. Perrett B. C. Jones 2008 Social perception of facial resemblance in humans Archives of Sexual Behavior 37 64 77.
E. Diener B. Wolsic F. Fujita 1995 Physical attractiveness and subjective well-being Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 69 120 129.
M. R. Dohm 2002 Repeatability estimates do not always set an upper limit to heritability Functional Ecology 16 273 280.
D. S. Falconer 1970 Introduction to Quantitative Genetics Oliver and Boyd Edinburgh.
J. C. Faure C. Rieffe J. C. Maltha 2002 The influence of different facial components on facial aesthetics European Journal of Orthodontics 24 1 7.
A. Feingold 1992 Good-looking people are not what we think Psychological Bulletin 111 304 341.
G. A. Ferguson Y. Takane 1989 Statistical Analysis in Psychology and Education McGraw-Hill New York.
M. L. Fisher 2004 Female intrasexual competition decreases female facial attractiveness Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 271 Suppl. S283 S285.
W. Forstmeier T. R. Birkhead 2004 Repeatability of mate choice in the zebra finch: Consistency within and between females Animal Behaviour 68 1017 1028.
S. W. Gangestad A. J. Cousins 2001 Adaptive design, female mate preferences, and shifts across the menstrual cycle Annual Review of Sex Research 12 145 185.
S. W. Gangestad R. Thornhill C. E. Garver-Apgar 2005 Adaptations to ovulation. Implications for sexual and social behavior Current Directions in Psychological Science 14 312 316.
S. W. Gangestad G. J. Scheyd 2005 The evolution of human physical attractiveness Annual Review of Anthropology 34 523 548.
C. Grønnerød 2003 Temporal stability in the Rorschach method: A meta-analytic review Journal of Personality Assessment 80 272 293.
J. Havlicek S.C. Roberts J. Flegr 2005 Women's preference for dominant male odour: Effects of menstrual cycle and relationship status Biology Letters 1 256 259.
M. Henneberg J. Piontek J. Strzałko 1978 Natural selection and morphological variability Current Anthropology 19 67 82.
L. Höfel T. Jacobsen 2003 Temporal stability and consistency of aesthetic judgments of beauty of formal graphic patterns Perceptual and Motor Skills 96 30 32.
M. J. Holveck K. Riebel 2007 Preferred songs predict preferred males: consistency and repeatability of zebra finch females across three test contexts Animal Behaviour 74 297 309.
J. Hönekopp 2006 Once more: Is beauty in the eye of the beholder? Relative contributions of private and shared taste to judgments of facial attractiveness Journal of Experimental Psychology 32 199 209.
R. D. Howard J. R. Young 1998 Individual variation in male vocal traits and female mating preferences in Bufo americanus Animal Behaviour 55 1165 1179.
D. J. Howells W. C. Shaw 1985 The validity and reliability of ratings of dental and facial attractiveness for epidemiologic use American Journal of Orthodontics 88 402 408.
M. D. Jennions P. R. Y. Backwell N. I. Passmore 1995 Repeatability of mate choice: the effect of size in the African painted reed frog, Hyperolius marmoratus Animal Behaviour 49 181 186.
M. D. Jennions M. Petrie 1997 Variation in mate choice and mating preferences: A review of causes and consequences Biological Reviews 72 283 327.
M. D. Jennions M. Petrie 2000 Why do females mate multiply? A review of the genetic benefits Biological Reviews 75 21 64.
V. S. Johnston R. Hagel M. Franklin B. Fink K. Grammer 2001 Male facial attractiveness — evidence for hormone-mediated adaptive design Evolution and Human Behavior 22 251 267.
B. C. Jones L. M. Debruine 2008 Adaptation reinforces preferences for correlates of attractive facial cues Visual Cognition 16 849 858.
B. C. Jones L. M. Debruine A. C. Little R. P. Burriss D. R. Feinberg 2007 Social transmission of face preferences among humans Proceedings of the Royal Society B 274 899 903.
B. C. Jones L. M. DeBruine A. C. Little D. R. Feinberg 2007 The valence of experiences with faces influences generalized preferences Journal of Evolutionary Psychology 5 119 129.
B. C. Jones L. M. DeBruine D. I. Perrett A. C. Little D. R. Feinberg M. J. Law Smith 2008 Effects of menstrual cycle phase on face preferences Archives of Sexual Behavior 37 78 84.
B. C. Jones A. C. Little D. R. Feinberg I. S. Penton-Voak B. P. Tiddeman D. I. Perrett 2004 The relationship between shape symmetry and perceived skin condition in male facial attractiveness Evolution and Human Behavior 25 24 30.
D. Jones 1996 Physical Attractiveness and the Theory of Sexual Selection University of Michigan, Museum of Anthropology Ann Arbor.
C. F. Keating J. Doyle 2002 The faces of desirable mates and dates contain mixed social status cues Journal of Experimental and Social Psychology 38 414 424.
A. Kodric-Brown P. F. Nicoletto 1997 Repeatability of female choice in the guppy: response to live and videotaped males Animal Behaviour 54 369 376.
K. Kościński 2008 Facial attractiveness: Variation, adaptiveness and consequences of facial preferences Anthropological Review 71 77 105.
J. H. Langlois L. Kalakanis A. J. Rubenstein A. Larson M. Hallam M. Smoot 2000 Maxims or myths of beauty Psychological Bulletin 126 390 423.
C. M. Lessells P. T. Boag 1987 Unrepeatable repeatabilities: A common mistake Auk 104 116 121.
A. C. Little L. M. Debruine B. C. Jones 2005 Sex-contingent face after-effects suggest distinct neural populations code male and female faces Proceedings of the Royal Society B 272 2283 2287.
A. C. Little B. C. Jones D. M. Burt D. I. Perrett 2007 Preferences for symmetry in faces change across the menstrual cycle Biological Psychology 76 209 216.
A. C. Little B. C. Jones I. S. Penton-Voak D. M. Burt D. I. Perrett 2002 Partnership status and the temporal context of relationships influence human female preferences for sexual dimorphism in male face shape Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 269 1095 1100.
A. C. Little H. Mannion 2006 Viewing attractive or unattractive same-sex individuals changes self-rated attractiveness and face preferences in women Animal Behavior 72 981 987.
J. R. Maple K. W. L. Vig F. M. Beck P. E. Larsen S. Shanker 2005 A comparison of providers’ and consumers’ perceptions of facial-profile attractiveness American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics 128 690 696.
A. P. Møller 1994 Repeatability of female choice in a monogamous swallow Animal Behaviour 47 643 648.
I. R. Olson C. Marshuetz 2005 Facial attractiveness is appraised in a glance Emotion 5 498 502.
L. L. C. Parker I. S. Penton-Voak A. S. Attwood M. R. Munaf 2008 Effects of acute alcohol consumption on ratings of attractiveness of facial stimuli: Evidence of long-term encoding Alcohol Alcoholism 43 636 640.
I. S. Penton-Voak D. I. Perrett D. L. Castles T. Kobayashi D. M. Burt L. K. Murray R. Minamisawa 1999 Menstrual cycle alters face preference Nature 399 741 742.
I. S. Penton-Voak D. I. Perrett 2000 Consistency and individual differences in facial attractiveness judgements: An evolutionary perspective Social Research 67 219 244.
I. S. Penton-Voak A. C. Little B. C. Jones D. M. Burt B. P. Tiddeman D. I. Perrett 2003 Female condition influences preferences for sexual dimorphism in faces of male humans (Homo sapiens) Journal of Comparative Psychology 117 264 271.
E. G. Pillsworth M. G. Haselton D. M. Buss 2004 Ovulatory shifts in female sexual desire Journal of Sex Research 41 55 65.
D. I. Perrett K. J. Lee I. Penton-Voak D. Rowland S. Yoshikawa D. M. Burt S. P. Henzi D. L. Castles S. Akamatsu 1998 Effects of sexual dimorphism on facial attractiveness Nature 394 884 887.
T. F. Pettijohn A. Tesser 2005 Threat and social choice: When eye size matters Journal of Social Psychology 145 547 570.
K. Reinhold K. Reinhold K. J. Jacoby 2002 Dissecting the repeatability of female choice in the grasshopper Chorthippus biguttulus Animal Behaviour 64 245 250.
G. Rhodes J. Halberstadt L. Jeffery R. Palermo 2005 The attractiveness of average faces is not a generalized mere exposure effect Social Cognition 23 205 217.
G. Rhodes L. Jeffery T. L. Watson C. W. G. Clifford K. Nakayama 2003 Fitting the mind to the world: Face adaptation and attractiveness aftereffects Psychological Science 14 558 566.
G. Rhodes K. Louw E. Evangelista 2009 Perceptual adaptation to facial asymmetries Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 16 503 508.
G. Rhodes J. Roberts L. W. Simmons 1999 Reflections on symmetry and attractiveness Psychology, Evolution and Gender 1 279 295.
G. Rhodes 2006 The evolutionary psychology of facial beauty Annual Review of Psychology 57 199 226.
B. W. Roberts W. F. Delvecchio 2000 The rank-order consistency of personality traits from childhood to old age: A quantitative review of longitudinal studies Psychological Bulletin 126 3 25.
S. C. Roberts L. M. Gosling V. Carter M. Petrie 2008 MHC-correlated odour preferences in humans and the use of oral contraceptives Proceedings of the Royal Society B 275 2715 2722.
M. L. Rosen H. H. López 2009 Menstrual cycle shifts in attentional bias for courtship language Evolution and Human Behavior 30 131 140.
D. A. Rowland D. I. Perrett 1995 Manipulating facial appearance through shape and color IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications 15 70 76.
J. M. Schuerger A. C. Witt 1989 The temporal stability of individually tested intelligence Journal of Clinical Psychology 45 294 302.
N. C. Silver W. P. Dunlap 1987 Averaging correlation coefficients: Should Fisher's z transformation be used? Journal of Applied Psychology 72 146 148.
J. A. Simpson S. W. Gangestad 1991 Individual differences in sociosexuality: Evidence for convergent and discriminant validity Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 60 870 883.
D. Symons 1995 Beauty is in the adaptation of the beholder: The evolutionary psychology of human female sexual attractiveness P. R. Abramson S.D. Pinkerton Sexual Nature/Sexual Culture University of Chicago Press Chicago 80 118.
A. Theodoridou A. C. Rowe I. S. Penton-Voak P. J. Rogers 2009 Oxytocin and social perception: Oxytocin increases perceived facial trustworthiness and attractiveness Hormones and Behavior 56 128 132.
Thayer, R. E. (1989): The Biopsychology of Mood and Arousal, Oxford University Press.
F. Thorne N. Neave A. Scholey M. Moss B. Fink 2002 Effects of putative male pheromones on female ratings of male attractiveness: Influence of oral contraceptives and the menstrual cycle Neuroendocrinology Letters 23 291 297.
J. Todrank D. Byrnes A. Wrzesniewski P. Rozin 1995 Odors can change preferences for people in photographs: A cross-modal evaluative conditioning study with olfactory USs and visual CSs Learning and Motivation 26 116 140.
W. E. Wagner 1998 Measuring female mating preferences Animal Behaviour 55 1029 1042.
W. E. Wagner A. M. Murray W. H. Cade 1995 Phenotypic variation in the mating preferences of female field crickets, Gryllus integer Animal Behaviour 49 1269 1281.
D. Waynforth S. Delwadia M. Camm 2005 The influence of women's mating strategies on preference for masculine facial architecture Evolution and Human Behavior 26 409 416.
L. A. Whittingham P. O. Dunn M. K. Stapleton 2006 Repeatability of extra-pair mating in tree swallows Molecular Ecology 15 841 849.
F. Widemo S. A. Sæther 1999 Beauty is in the eye of beholder: Causes and consequences of variation in mating preferences Trends in Ecology and Evolution 14 26 31.
Wong, D. T. & Cunningham, M. R. (1990): Interior versus exterior beauty: The effects of mood on dating preferences for different types of physically attractive women. Paper presented at the Southeastern Psychological Association, Atlanta, GA.
R. B. Zajonc 2001 Mere exposure: A gateway to the subliminal Current Directions in Psychological Science 10 224 228.