This paper investigates the effect of larynx position on the articulatory abilities of a human-like vocal tract. Previous work has investigated models that were built to resemble the anatomy of existing species or fossil ancestors. This has led to conflicting conclusions about the relation between the evolution of anatomy and the evolution of speech. Here a model is proposed to systematically investigate the relation between larynx height and articulatory abilities. It is a simplified model of primate vocal anatomy that nevertheless preserves the essential articulatory constraints due to limitations of muscular control. It is found that there is an optimal larynx height at which the largest range of signals can be produced and that at this height, the vertical and horizontal parts are approximately equally long. This has been a conjecture for a long time by those researchers of the evolution of speech who propose that the human vocal tract has evolved for speech. A short recapitulation of acoustic theory of speech production is presented to explain the reason for why this configuration is optimal.
The optimal configuration corresponds closely to human female anatomy, while in the human male the larynx is slightly lower than optimal. These results agree with the hypothesis that modern human vocal anatomy has evolved because of speech, and that male larynx position might have been lowered further for reasons of size exaggeration.
L.-J. Boë J.-L. Heim K. Honda S. Maeda 2002 The potential Neandertal vowel space was as large as that of modern humans Journal of Phonetics 30 3 465 484.
L.-J. Boë J.-L. Heim K. Honda S. Maeda P. Badin C. Abry 2007 The vocal tract of newborn humans and Neanderthals: Acoustic capabilities and consequences for the debate on the origin of language. A reply to Lieberman (2007a) Journal of Phonetics 35 4 564 581.
Boë, L.-J., Perrier, P., Guerin, B. & Schwartz, J.-L. (1989): Maximal Vowel Space. Paper presented at the Eurospeech, Paris, France.
P. Boersma 1998 Functional Phonology Holland Academic Graphics The Hague.
R. Carré 2004 From an acoustic tube to speech production Speech Communication 42 2 227 240.
R. Carré 2009 Dynamic properties of an acoustic tube: Prediction of vowel systems Speech Communication 51 1 26 41.
R. Carré B. Lindblom P. F. Macneilage 1995 Rôle de l'acoustique dans l’évolution du conduit vocal humain Comptes Rendus de l'Académie des Sciences, Série II 320 sérieIIb 471 476.
R. Carré M. Mrayati 1995 Vowel transitions, vowel systems, and the distinctive region model C. Sorin M. Wajskop Levels in Speech Communication: Relations and Interactions Elsevier Amsterdam 73 89.
J. D. Choi 1995 An acoustic-phonetic underspecification account of marshallese vowel allophony Journal of Phonetics 23 323 347.
B. de Boer 2000 Self organization in vowel systems Journal of Phonetics 28 4 441 465.
B. de Boer 2009 Why women speak better than men (and its significance for evolution) R. Botha C. Knight The Prehistory of Language (eds) Oxford University Press Oxford 255 265.
B. de Boer W. T. Fitch 2010 Computer models of vocal tract evolution: An overview and critique Adaptive Behavior 18 1 36 47.
D. Demolin V. Delvaux 2006 A comparison of the articulatory parameters involved in the production of sounds of bonobos and modern humans A. Cangelosi A. D. M. Smith K. Smith The Evolution of Language: Proceedings of the 6th International Conference (evolang6) World Scientific New Jersey 67 74.
R. L. Diehl B. Lindblom K. A. Hoemeke R. P. Fahey 1996 On explaining certain male-female differences in the phonetic realization of vowel categories Journal of Phonetics 24 2 187 208.
G. Fant 1960 Acoustic Theory of Speech Production Mouton ‘sGravenhage.
G. Fant 1975 Non-uniform vowel normalization Speech Transmission Laboratory Quarterly Progress and Status Report 16 2–3 1 19.
W. T. Fitch 2000 The evolution of speech: A comparative review Trends in Cognitive Sciences 4 7 258 267.
W. T. Fitch J. Giedd 1999 Morphology and development of the human vocal tract: A study using magnetic resonance imaging Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 106 3Pt.1 1511 1522.
W. T. Fitch M. D. Hauser 2003 Unpacking “honesty”: Vertebrate vocal production and the evolution of acoustic signals A. M. Simmons R. R. Fay A. N. Popper Acoustic Communication Springer New York 65 137.
W. T. Fitch D. Reby 2001 The descended larynx is not uniquely human Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B — Biological Sciences 268 1669 1675.
J. L. Flanagan 1965 Speech Analysis, Synthesis and Perception Springer Berlin.
U. G. Goldstein 1980 An Articulatory Model for the Vocal Tracts of Growing Children Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge (MA).
H. J. Heimlich 1975 A life-saving maneuver to prevent food-choking Journal of the American Medical Association 234 4 398 401.
P. H. Lieberman 2007 Current views on Neanderthal speech capabilities: A reply to Boë et al. (2002) Journal of Phonetics 35 4 552 563.
P. H. Lieberman E. S. Crelin 1971 On the speech of Neanderthal man Linguistic Inquiry 2 203 222.
P. H. Lieberman E. S. Crelin D. H. Klatt 1972 Phonetic ability and related anatomy of the newborn and adult human, Neanderthal man, and the chimpanzee American Anthropologist 74 287 307.
B. Lindblom P. F. Macneilage M. Studdert-Kennedy 1984 Self-organizing processes and the explanation of language universals M. Butterworth B. Comrie Dahl Explanations for Language Universals Walter de Gruyter & Co. Berlin 181 203.
A. Maclarnon G. P. Hewitt 1999 The evolution of human speech: The role of enhanced breathing control American Journal of Physical Anthropology 109 3 341 343.
A. Maclarnon G. P. Hewitt 2004 Increased breathing control: Another factor in the evolution of human language Evolutionary Anthropology 13 181 197.
S. Maeda 1990 Compensatory articulation during speech: Evidence from the analysis and synthesis of vocal tract shapes using an articulatory model W. J. Hardcastle A. Marchal Speech Production and Speech Modelling Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht 131 149.
P. Mermelstein 1973 Articulatory model for the study of speech production Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 53 4 1070 1082.
V. E. Negus 1938 Evolution of the speech organs of man Archives of Otolaryngology 28 313 328.
M. A. Nowak D. Krakauer A. Dress 1999 An error limit for the evolution of language Proceedings of the Royal Society of London 266 2131 2136.
J. J. Ohala 1984 An ethological perspective on common cross-language utilization of f0 of voice Phonetica 41 1 1 16.
D. A. Puts S. J. C. Gaulin K. Verdolini 2006 Dominance and the evolution of sexual dimorphism in human voice pitch Evolution and Human Behavior 27 4 283 296.
M. R. Schroeder 1967 Determination of the geometry of the human vocal tract by acoustic measurements Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 41 4Pt.2 1002 1010.
M. R. Schroeder B. S. Atal J. L. Hall 1979 Objective measure of certain speech signal degradations based on masking properties of human auditory perception B. Lindblom S. Öhman Frontiers of Speech Communication Research Academic Press London 217 229.
B. H. Story I. R. Titze E. A. Hoffman 1996 Vocal tract area functions from magnetic resonance imaging Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 100 1 537 554.
B. H. Story I. R. Titze E. A. Hoffman 1998 Vocal tract area functions for an adult female speaker based on volumetric imaging Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 104 1 471 487.
W. Zuidema B. de Boer 2009 The evolution of combinatorial phonology Journal of Phonetics 37 2 125 144.