Community Ecology
Volume/Issue:
Volume 9: Issue 2
Imperfect detection and its consequences for monitoring for conservation
Authors:
M. Kéry Swiss Ornithological Institute 6204 Sempach Switzerland

Search for other papers by M. Kéry in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed Close
and
B. Schmidt

Search for other papers by B. Schmidt in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed Close
Pages:
207–216
Online Publication Date:
10 Dec 2008
Publication Date:
01 Dec 2008
Article Category:
Research Article
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1556/comec.9.2008.2.10
Keywords:
Abundance; Availability; Biodiversity; Detectability; Distribution; Inventory; Monitoring; Occupancy; Sampling; Survey
Restricted access

Biodiversity monitoring is important to identify conservation needs and test the efficacy of management actions. Variants of “abundance” ( N ) are among the most widely monitored quantities, e.g., (true) abundance, number of occupied sites (distribution, occupancy) or species richness. We propose a sampling-based view of monitoring that clearly acknowledges two sampling processes involved when monitoring N . First, measurements from the surveyed sample area are generalized to a larger area, hence the importance of a probability sample. Second, even within sampled areas only a sample of units (individuals, occupied sites, species) is counted owing to imperfect detectability p . If p < 1, counts are random variables and their expectation E ( n ) is related to N via the relationship E ( n ) = N*p . Whenever p < 1, counts vary even under identical conditions and underestimate N , and patterns in counts confound patterns in N with those in p . In addition, part of the population N may be unavailable for detection, e.g., temporarily outside the sampled quadrat, underground or for another reason not exposed to sampling; hence a more general way of describing a count is E ( n ) = N*a*p , where a is availability probability and p detection, given availability. We give two examples of monitoring schemes that highlight the importance of explicitly accounting for availability and detectability. In the Swiss reptile Red List update, the widespread and abundant slow worm ( Anguis fragilis ) was recorded in only 22.1% of all sampled quadrats. Only an analysis that accounted for both availability and detectability gave realistic estimates of the species’ distribution. Among 128 bird species monitored in the Swiss breeding bird survey, detection in occupied 1 km 2 quadrats averaged only 64% and varied tremendously by species (3–99 %); hence observed distributions greatly underestimated range sizes and should not be compared among species. We believe that monitoring design and analyses should properly account for these two sampling processes to enable valid inferences about biodiversity. We argue for a more rigorous approach to both monitoring design and analysis to obtain the best possible information about the state of nature. An explicit recognition of, and proper accounting for, the two sampling processes involved in most monitoring programs will go a long way towards this goal.

  • AERC TAC’s Taxonomic Recommendations. 2003. http://www.aerc.eu/aerc_tac.htm

  • Anderson, D.R. 2001. The need to get the basics right in wildlife field studies. Wildlife Soc. Bull. 29:1294–1297.

    Anderson D.R. , 'The need to get the basics right in wildlife field studies ' (2001 ) 29 Wildlife Soc. Bull. : 1294 -1297 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Bart, J., S. Droege, P. Geissler, B. Peterjohn and C.J. Ralph. 2004. Density estimation in wildlife surveys. Wildlife Soc. Bull. 32:1242–1247.

    Ralph C.J. , 'Density estimation in wildlife surveys ' (2004 ) 32 Wildlife Soc. Bull. : 1242 -1247 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Buckland, S.T., D.R. Anderson, K.P. Burnham, J.L. Laake, D. L. Borchers and L. Thomas. 2001. Introduction to Distance Sampling . Oxford University Press, Oxford.

    Thomas L. , '', in Introduction to Distance Sampling , (2001 ) -.

  • Burnham, K.P. and D. R. Anderson. 2002. Model Selection and Multimodel Inference: A Practical Information Theoretic Approach . 2 ed. Springer, New York.

    Anderson D. R. , '', in Model Selection and Multimodel Inference: A Practical Information Theoretic Approach , (2002 ) -.

  • Condit, R., B.J. Le Boeuf, P. A. Morris and M. Sylvan. 2007. Estimating population size in asynchronous aggregations: A Bayesian approach and test with elephant seal censuses. Marine Mammal Sci. 23:834–855.

    Sylvan M. , 'Estimating population size in asynchronous aggregations: A Bayesian approach and test with elephant seal censuses ' (2007 ) 23 Marine Mammal Sci. : 834 -855 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Gelman, A. and J. Hill. 2007. Data Analysis Using Regression and Multilevel/hierarchical Models . Cambridge University Press, New York.

    Hill J. , '', in Data Analysis Using Regression and Multilevel/hierarchical Models , (2007 ) -.

  • Hochachka, W.M. and W. Fiedler. 2008. Trends in trappability and stopover duration can confound interpretations of population trajectories from long-term migration ringing studies. J. Ornithol. 149: 375–391.

    Fiedler W. , 'Trends in trappability and stopover duration can confound interpretations of population trajectories from long-term migration ringing studies ' (2008 ) 149 J. Ornithol. : 375 -391 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Hofer, U., J.-C. Monney and G. Dušej. 2001. I rettili della Svizzera: Distribuzione, habitat, protezione . Birkhäuser Verlag, Basel.

    Dušej G. , '', in I rettili della Svizzera: Distribuzione, habitat, protezione , (2001 ) -.

  • Johnson, D.H. 2008. In defense of indices. J. Wildlife Manage. 72: 857–868.

    Johnson D.H. , 'In defense of indices ' (2008 ) 72 J. Wildlife Manage. : 857 -868 .

  • Joseph, L.N., S.A. Field, C. Wilcox and H.P. Possingham. 2006. Presence-absence versus abundance data for monitoring threatened species. Conserv. Biol. 20:1679–1687.

    Possingham H.P. , 'Presence-absence versus abundance data for monitoring threatened species ' (2006 ) 20 Conserv. Biol. : 1679 -1687 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Kendall, W.L. 1999. Robustness of closed capture-recapture methods to violations of the closure assumption. Ecology 80:2517–2525.

    Kendall W.L. , 'Robustness of closed capture-recapture methods to violations of the closure assumption ' (1999 ) 80 Ecology : 2517 -2525 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Kéry, M. 2002. Inferring the absence of a species — A case study of snakes. J. Wildlife Manage. 66:330–338.

    Kéry M. , 'Inferring the absence of a species — A case study of snakes ' (2002 ) 66 J. Wildlife Manage. : 330 -338 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Kéry, M., J.A. Royle, M. Plattner and R.M. Dorazio. in press. Species richness and occupancy estimation in communities subject to temporary emigration. Ecology .

  • Kéry, M. and H. Schmid. 2006. Estimating species richness: Calibrating a large avian monitoring program. J. App. Ecol. 43:101–110.

    Schmid H. , 'Estimating species richness: Calibrating a large avian monitoring program ' (2006 ) 43 J. App. Ecol. : 101 -110 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Kéry, M., J.H. Spillmann, C. Truong and R. Holderegger. 2006. How biased are estimates of extinction probability in revisitation studies? J. Ecol. 94:980–986.

    Holderegger R. , 'How biased are estimates of extinction probability in revisitation studies? ' (2006 ) 94 J. Ecol. : 980 -986 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Link, W.A. and J. R. Sauer. 2007. Seasonal components of avian population change: Joint analysis of two large-scale monitoring programs. Ecology 88:49–55.

    Sauer J. R. , 'Seasonal components of avian population change: Joint analysis of two large-scale monitoring programs ' (2007 ) 88 Ecology : 49 -55 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Little, R.J. 2004. To model or not to model? Competing modes of inference in finite population sampling. J. Amer. Stat. Assoc. 99:546–556.

    Little R.J. , 'To model or not to model? Competing modes of inference in finite population sampling ' (2004 ) 99 J. Amer. Stat. Assoc. : 546 -556 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • MacKenzie, D.I. 2005. What are the issues with presence-absence data for wildlife managers? J. Wildlife Manage. 69:849–860.

    MacKenzie D.I. , 'What are the issues with presence-absence data for wildlife managers? ' (2005 ) 69 J. Wildlife Manage. : 849 -860 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • MacKenzie, D.I. and W.L. Kendall. 2002. How should detection probability be incorporated into estimates of relative abundance? Ecology 83:2387–2393.

    Kendall W.L. , 'How should detection probability be incorporated into estimates of relative abundance? ' (2002 ) 83 Ecology : 2387 -2393 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • MacKenzie, D.I., J.D. Nichols, J.E. Hines, M.G. Knutson and A.D. Franklin. 2003. Estimating site occupancy, colonization and local extinction when a species is detected imperfectly. Ecology 84:2200–2207.

    Franklin A.D. , 'Estimating site occupancy, colonization and local extinction when a species is detected imperfectly ' (2003 ) 84 Ecology : 2200 -2207 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • MacKenzie, D.I., J.D. Nichols, G.B. Lachman, S. Droege, J.A. Royle and C.A. Langtimm. 2002. Estimating site occupancy rates when detection probability rates are less than one. Ecology 83:2248–2255.

    Langtimm C.A. , 'Estimating site occupancy rates when detection probability rates are less than one ' (2002 ) 83 Ecology : 2248 -2255 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • MacKenzie, D.I., J.D. Nichols, J.A. Royle, K.H. Pollock, J.E. Hines and L.L. Bailey. 2006. Occupancy Estimation and Modeling: Inferring Patterns and Dynamics of Species Occurrence Elsevier, San Diego.

    Bailey L.L. , '', in Occupancy Estimation and Modeling: Inferring Patterns and Dynamics of Species Occurrence , (2006 ) -.

  • Marsh, H., and D. F. Sinclair. 1989. Correcting for visibility bias in strip transect aerial surveys of aquatic fauna. J. Wildlife Manage. 53:1017–1024.

    Sinclair D. F. , 'Correcting for visibility bias in strip transect aerial surveys of aquatic fauna ' (1989 ) 53 J. Wildlife Manage. : 1017 -1024 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Mazerolle, M.J., L.L. Bailey, W.L. Kendall, J.A. Royle, S.J. Converse and J.D. Nichols. 2007. Making great leaps forward: Accounting for detectability in herpetological field studies. J. Herpetol. 41:672–689.

    Nichols J.D. , 'Making great leaps forward: Accounting for detectability in herpetological field studies ' (2007 ) 41 J. Herpetol. : 672 -689 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Monney, J.-C. and A. Meyer. 2005. Rote Liste der gefährdeten Reptilien der Schweiz . Bundesamt für Umwelt, Wald und Landschaft, Bern, and Koordinationsstelle für Amphibien- und Reptilienschutz in der Schweiz, Bern.

    Meyer A. , '', in Rote Liste der gefährdeten Reptilien der Schweiz , (2005 ) -.

  • Nichols, J.D., L. Thomas. and P.B. Conn. 2008. Inferences about landbird abundance from count data: recent advances and future directions. Environmental and Ecological Statistics , in press.

  • Pollock, K.H., H. Marsh, L.L. Bailey, G.L. Farnsworth, T.R. Simons and M.W. Alldredge. 2004. Separating components of detection probability in abundance estimation: An overview with diverse examples. In: W.L. Thompson (ed.), Sampling Rare or Elusive Species . Island Press, Washington, USA. pp. 43–58.

    Alldredge M.W. , '', in Sampling Rare or Elusive Species , (2004 ) -.

  • Reading, C.J. 1997. A proposed standard method for surveying reptiles on dry lowland heath. J. App. Ecol. 34:1057–1069.

    Reading C.J. , 'A proposed standard method for surveying reptiles on dry lowland heath ' (1997 ) 34 J. App. Ecol. : 1057 -1069 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Royle, J.A. 2006. Site occupancy models with heterogeneous detection probabilities. Biometrics 62:97–102.

    Royle J.A. , 'Site occupancy models with heterogeneous detection probabilities ' (2006 ) 62 Biometrics : 97 -102 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Royle, J.A. and R. M. Dorazio. 2006. Hierarchical models of animal abundance and occurrence. J. Agric. Biol. Environ. Stat. 11:249–263.

    Dorazio R. M. , 'Hierarchical models of animal abundance and occurrence ' (2006 ) 11 J. Agric. Biol. Environ. Stat. : 249 -263 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Royle, J.A. and R. M. Dorazio. 2008. Hierarchical Modeling and Inference in Ecology . Academic Press, Amsterdam.

    Dorazio R. M. , '', in Hierarchical Modeling and Inference in Ecology , (2008 ) -.

  • Royle, J.A. and M. Kéry. 2007. A Bayesian state-space formulation of dynamic occupancy models. Ecology 88:1813–1823.

    Kéry M. , 'A Bayesian state-space formulation of dynamic occupancy models ' (2007 ) 88 Ecology : 1813 -1823 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Royle, J.A., M. Kéry, R. Gautier and H. Schmid. 2007. Hierarchical spatial models of abundance and occurrence from imperfect survey data. Ecol. Monogr. 77:465–481.

    Schmid H. , 'Hierarchical spatial models of abundance and occurrence from imperfect survey data ' (2007 ) 77 Ecol. Monogr. : 465 -481 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Royle, J.A. and W.A. Link. 2006. Generalized occupancy models allowing false positive and false negative errors. Ecology 87:835–841.

    Link W.A. , 'Generalized occupancy models allowing false positive and false negative errors ' (2006 ) 87 Ecology : 835 -841 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Schmid, H., N. Zbinden V. and Keller. 2004. Überwachung der Bestandsentwicklung häufiger Brutvögel in der Schweiz . Swiss Ornithological Institute, Sempach, Switzerland.

    Keller , '', in Überwachung der Bestandsentwicklung häufiger Brutvögel in der Schweiz , (2004 ) -.

  • Schmidt, B.R. 2004. Declining amphibian populations: The pitfalls of count data in the study of diversity, distributions, dynamics, and demography. Herpetol. J. 14:167–174.

    Schmidt B.R. , 'Declining amphibian populations: The pitfalls of count data in the study of diversity, distributions, dynamics, and demography ' (2004 ) 14 Herpetol. J. : 167 -174 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Schmidt, B.R. 2005. Monitoring the distribution of pond-breeding amphibians when species are detected imperfectly. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 15:681–692.

    Schmidt B.R. , 'Monitoring the distribution of pond-breeding amphibians when species are detected imperfectly ' (2005 ) 15 Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems : 681 -692 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Spiegelhalter, D., A. Thomas and N.G. Best. 2003. WinBUGS User Manual, Version 1.4 ., MCR Biostatistics Unit, Cambridge.

    Best N.G. , '', in WinBUGS User Manual, Version 1.4 , (2003 ) -.

  • Thompson, S.K. 2002. Sampling . Wiley, New York.

    Thompson S.K. , '', in Sampling , (2002 ) -.

  • Thompson, W.L. 2004. Sampling Rare and Elusive Species . Island Press, Washington.

    Thompson W.L. , '', in Sampling Rare and Elusive Species , (2004 ) -.

  • Weber, D., U. Hintermann and A. Zangger. 2004. Scale and trends in species richness: considerations for monitoring biological diversity for political purposes. Global Ecol. Biogeogr. 13:97–104.

    Zangger A. , 'Scale and trends in species richness: considerations for monitoring biological diversity for political purposes ' (2004 ) 13 Global Ecol. Biogeogr. : 97 -104 .

    • Search Google Scholar

  • Williams, B.K., J.D. Nichols and M.J. Conroy. 2002. Analysis and Management of Animal Populations . Academic Press, San Diego.

    Conroy M.J. , '', in Analysis and Management of Animal Populations , (2002 ) -.
  • Collapse
  • Expand
Cover Community Ecology
Community Ecology An Interdisciplinary Journal Reporting Progress in Community and Population Studies
Print ISSN:
1585-8553
Online ISSN:
1588-2756

To see the editorial board, please visit the website of Springer Nature.

Manuscript Submission: HERE

For subscription options, please visit the website of Springer Nature.

Community Ecology
Language English
Size A4
Year of
Foundation		 2000
Volumes
per Year		 1
Issues
per Year		 3
Founder Akadémiai Kiadó
Founder's
Address		 H-1117 Budapest, Hungary 1516 Budapest, PO Box 245
Publisher Akadémiai Kiadó
Springer Nature Switzerland AG
Publisher's
Address		 H-1117 Budapest, Hungary 1516 Budapest, PO Box 245.
CH-6330 Cham, Switzerland Gewerbestrasse 11.
Responsible
Publisher		 Chief Executive Officer, Akadémiai Kiadó
ISSN 1585-8553 (Print)
ISSN 1588-2756 (Online)

Monthly Content Usage

Abstract Views Full Text Views PDF Downloads
Aug 2024 86 9 11
Sep 2024 93 1 1
Oct 2024 173 2 2
Nov 2024 90 0 0
Dec 2024 72 0 0
Jan 2025 52 0 0
Feb 2025 0 0 0