View More View Less
  • 1 University of Vaasa Faculty of Public Administration Vaasa Finland
Restricted access

It is most often the case that planners of health care reforms and policies try to solve highly complex, or wicked problems. Issues that have no single experts. Collectively, by gathering many different people and bringing them to genuine deliberation, we can, however, create an emergent understanding and commitment, which helps us to tackle these problems. In this study, the prospects of public deliberation in the late Hungarian health insurance reform are examined. The Hungarian health insurance reform, as a highly debated and ultimately failed reform, is considered to be a useful model to exemplify the prospects of public deliberation. The objective is to point out how public deliberation could have improved the process of reforming the Hungarian health care.

  • Akkazieva, B. — Gulacsi, L. — Brandtmuller, A. — Pentek, M. — Bridges, J. (2006): Patients’ Preferences for Healthcare System Reforms in Hungary: A Conjoint Analysis, Applied Health Economics and Health Policy 5(3): 189–198.

    Bridges J. , 'Patients’ Preferences for Healthcare System Reforms in Hungary: A Conjoint Analysis ' (2006 ) 5 Applied Health Economics and Health Policy : 189 -198.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Anderson, R. A. — McDaniel, R. R. Jr. (2000): Managing Health Care Organizations: Where Professionalism Meets Complexity Science. Health Care Management Review 25(1): 83–92.

    McDaniel R. R. , 'Managing Health Care Organizations: Where Professionalism Meets Complexity Science ' (2000 ) 25 Health Care Management Review : 83 -92.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • APS (2007): Tackling Wicked Problems: A Public Policy Perspective . Australian Government, Australian Public Service Commission.

  • Atlee, T. (2004): Critiquing AmericaSpeaks’ Process and Alternative Approaches as Paths to “Collective Intelligence”. Group Facilitating 6: 93–101.

    Atlee T. , 'Critiquing AmericaSpeaks’ Process and Alternative Approaches as Paths to “Collective Intelligence” ' (2004 ) 6 Group Facilitating : 93 -101.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Begun, J.W. — Zimmerman, B. — Dooley, K. (2003): Health Care Organizations as Complex Adaptive Systems. In: Mick, S. M. — Wyttenbach, M. (eds): Advances in Health Care Organization Theory . San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, pp. 253–288.

    Dooley K. , '', in Advances in Health Care Organization Theory , (2003 ) -.

  • Bennett, P. — Smith, S. J. (2007): Genetics, Insurance and Participation: How a Citizens’ Jury reached its verdict. Social Science & Medicine 64(12): 2487–2498.

    Smith S. J. , 'Genetics, Insurance and Participation: How a Citizens’ Jury reached its verdict ' (2007 ) 64 Social Science & Medicine : 2487 -2498.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Bonch, I. (2009): Politics and Policy in Health Versus Health in Politics and Policy. Presentation in Finnish-Hungarian Health-economics Conference at the Corvinus University of Budapest on 5 th of February 2009 (Searching for the holy grail of health policies: The Finnish-Hungarian alliance).

  • Brown, C. A. (2006): Reconceptualizing Chronic Pain as a Complex Adaptive System. Emergence 8(3): 2–11.

    Brown C. A. , 'Reconceptualizing Chronic Pain as a Complex Adaptive System ' (2006 ) 8 Emergence : 2 -11.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Clarke, M. — Stewart, J. (2000): Handling the Wicked Issues. In: Davies, C. — Finlay, L. — Bullman, A. (eds): Changing Practice in Health and Social Care . London: Sage, pp. 377–386.

    Stewart J. , '', in Changing Practice in Health and Social Care , (2000 ) -.

  • Cohen, J. (1991): Deliberation and Democratic Legitimacy. In: Hamlin, A., Pettit, P. (eds): Good Polity Normative Analysis of the State . Oxford: Blackwell.

    Cohen J. , '', in Good Polity Normative Analysis of the State , (1991 ) -.

  • Conklin, J. (2005): Dialogue Mapping: Building Shared Understanding of Wicked Problems . New York: Wiley.

    Conklin J. , '', in Dialogue Mapping: Building Shared Understanding of Wicked Problems , (2005 ) -.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Declaration of Alma-Ata (1978): International Conference on Primary Health Care , Alma-Ata, USSR, 6–12 September.

    '', in International Conference on Primary Health Care , (1978 ) -.

  • Edelényi, M. (2008): Government Performs Unexpected U-turn on Health Reform Bill. Eurofound document . Available 2 nd July 2009 at http://www.eurofound.europa.eu/eiro/2008/06/articles/hu0806029i.htm

  • Edelényi, M. — Neumann, L. — Tóth, A. (2008): Coalition parties divided over controversial health insurance reform. Eurofound document . Available 2 nd July 2009 at http://www.eurofound.europa.eu/eiro/2008/03/articles/HU0803029I.htm

  • Foresight (2007): Tackling Obesities: Future Choices . London: Government Office for Science.

    Foresight , '', in Tackling Obesities: Future Choices , (2007 ) -.

  • Friedman, W. (2006): Deliberative Democracy and the Problem of Scope. Journal of Public Deliberation 2(1).

  • Fung, A. (2003): Survey Article: Recipes for Public Spheres: Eight Institutional Design Choices and Their Concequences. The Journal of Political Philosophy 11(3): 338–367.

    Fung A. , 'Survey Article: Recipes for Public Spheres: Eight Institutional Design Choices and Their Concequences ' (2003 ) 11 The Journal of Political Philosophy : 338 -367.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Glouberman, S. (2006): Complicated and Complex Systems . European Health Leadership Programme INSEAD

  • Grimes, M. F. (2008): The Civic Benefits of Imperfect Deliberation. Journal of Public Deliberation 4(1).

  • Gulácsi, L. — Brodszky, V. — Péntek, M. — Varga, S. — Vas, G. — Boncz, I. (2009): History of Health Technology Assessment in Hungary. International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 25(1): 1–7.

    Boncz I. , 'History of Health Technology Assessment in Hungary ' (2009 ) 25 International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care : 1 -7.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Hakkarainen, K. (2003): Kollektiivinen älykkyys. Psykologia 38(6): 384–401.

    Hakkarainen K. , 'Kollektiivinen älykkyys ' (2003 ) 38 Psykologia : 384 -401.

  • Hartz-Karp, J. (2007): How and Why Deliberative Democracy Enables Co-Intelligence and Brings Wisdom to Governance. Journal of Public Deliberation 3(1).

  • Hendriks, C. M. (2006): Integrated Deliberation: Reconciling Civil Society’s Dual Role in Deliberative Democracy. Political Studies 54(3): 486–508.

    Hendriks C. M. , 'Integrated Deliberation: Reconciling Civil Society’s Dual Role in Deliberative Democracy ' (2006 ) 54 Political Studies : 486 -508.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Horvath, J. (2007): Hungarian Health Reform: Back to the Future? Telepolis 23(2).

  • Iredale, R. — Longley, M. (1999): Public Involvement in Policy-making: The case of a Citizens’ Jury on genetic testing for common disorders. Journal of Consumer Studies & Home Economics 23(1): 3–10.

    Longley M. , 'Public Involvement in Policy-making: The case of a Citizens’ Jury on genetic testing for common disorders ' (1999 ) 23 Journal of Consumer Studies & Home Economics : 3 -10.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Iredale, R. — Longley, M. — Thomas, C. — Shaw, A. (2006): What Choices Should We Be Able to Make about Designer Babies? A Citizens’ Jury of young people in South Wales. Health Expectation 9(3): 207–217.

    Shaw A. , 'What Choices Should We Be Able to Make about Designer Babies? A Citizens’ Jury of young people in South Wales ' (2006 ) 9 Health Expectation : 207 -217.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Jenei, G. (2008): A Post-accession Crisis? Political Developments and Public Sector Modernisation in Hungary. NISPAcee Journal of Public Administration and Policy 1(2): 55–67.

    Jenei G. , 'A Post-accession Crisis? Political Developments and Public Sector Modernisation in Hungary ' (2008 ) 1 NISPAcee Journal of Public Administration and Policy : 55 -67.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Kadlec, A. — Friedman, W. (2007): Deliberative Democracy and the Problem of Power. Journal of Public Deliberation 3(1).

  • Kauffman, S. (1995): At Home in the Universe: The Search for the Laws of Self Organization and Complexity . Oxford: Oxford University Press.

    Kauffman S. , '', in At Home in the Universe: The Search for the Laws of Self Organization and Complexity , (1995 ) -.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Kenyon, W. — Nevin, C. — Hanley, N. (2003): Enhancing Environmental Decision-making using Citizens’ Juries. Local Environment 8(2): 221–232.

    Hanley N. , 'Enhancing Environmental Decision-making using Citizens’ Juries ' (2003 ) 8 Local Environment : 221 -232.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Keskinen, A. — Kuosa, T. (2004): Uusi aikakausi vaatii uudenlaista demokratiaa (The New Era Calls for New Democracy). Futura 2.

  • King, J. B. (1993): Learning to Solve the Right Problems: The Case of Nuclear Power in America. Journal of Business Ethics 12(2): 105–116.

    King J. B. , 'Learning to Solve the Right Problems: The Case of Nuclear Power in America ' (1993 ) 12 Journal of Business Ethics : 105 -116.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Kutzin, K. (2007): WHO’s perspective on the proposed reforms to the Hungarian health insurance system . Presentation in Health Insurance Reform 2007–2009, 25–26. January 2007, Budapest, Hungary.

  • Lalonde, M. (2002): New Perspective on the Health of Canadians: 28 years later. Public Health 12(3): 149–152.

    Lalonde M. , 'New Perspective on the Health of Canadians: 28 years later ' (2002 ) 12 Public Health : 149 -152.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Ludwig, D. (2001): The Era of Management is Over. Ecosystem 4(8): 758–764.

    Ludwig D. , 'The Era of Management is Over ' (2001 ) 4 Ecosystem : 758 -764.

  • Mattinson, D. (1999): People Power in Politics. Journal of the Market Research Society 41(1): 87–95.

    Mattinson D. , 'People Power in Politics ' (1999 ) 41 Journal of the Market Research Society : 87 -95.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Mihályi, P., ed. (2007): Health Insurance Reform in Hungary, Volume 1, Plans and dilemmas . Budapest: Europe Ltd.

    '', in Health Insurance Reform in Hungary, Volume 1, Plans and dilemmas , (2007 ) -.

  • Mihályi, P., ed. (2008a): Health Insurance Reform in Hungary, Volume 2. Rise and fall . Budapest: Europe Ltd.

    '', in Health Insurance Reform in Hungary, Volume 2. Rise and fall , (2008 ) -.

  • Mihályi, P. (2008b): The Rise and Fall of the New Health Insurance Act. In: Mihályi, P., ed.: Health Insurance Reform in Hungary, Volume 2. Rise and fall , Budapest: Europe Ltd.

    Mihályi P. , '', in Health Insurance Reform in Hungary, Volume 2. Rise and fall , (2008 ) -.

  • Murphy, N. J. (2005): Citizen deliberation in setting health-care priorities. Health Expectation 8(2): 172–181.

    Murphy N. J. , 'Citizen deliberation in setting health-care priorities ' (2005 ) 8 Health Expectation : 172 -181.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • NHS (2008): Our NHS, Our Future . Available on the 6 th of March 2008 at http://www.ournhs.nhs.uk

  • OECD (2008): Reforms for Stability and Sustainable Growth: An OECD Perspective on Hungary . Paris: OECD.

    '', in Reforms for Stability and Sustainable Growth: An OECD Perspective on Hungary , (2008 ) -.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Peirce, J. C. (2000): The Paradox of Physicians and Administrators in Health Care Organizations. Health Care Management Review 25(1): 7–28.

    Peirce J. C. , 'The Paradox of Physicians and Administrators in Health Care Organizations ' (2000 ) 25 Health Care Management Review : 7 -28.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Raisio, H. (forthcoming): Health Care Reform Planners and Wicked Problems: Is the wickedness of the problems taken seriously or is it even noticed at all? Journal of Health Organization and Management .

  • Raisio, H. — Vartiainen, P. — Ersek, K. — Gulacsi, L. (2009): Health Economics and Deliberative Democracy in Health Care Priority Setting: ’symbiosis’ of technocratic and democratic values. Paper presented at the conference Governing Good and Governing Well: The first global dialogue on ethical and effective governance , 28–30 May 2009, Amsterdam.

  • Randma-Liiv, T. (2008): New Public Management Versus the Neo-Weberian State in Central and Eastern Europe. The NISPAcee Journal of Public Administration and Policy 1(2): 69–81

    Randma-Liiv T. , 'New Public Management Versus the Neo-Weberian State in Central and Eastern Europe ' (2008 ) 1 The NISPAcee Journal of Public Administration and Policy : 69 -81.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Rawlins, M. D. (2005): Phamacopolitics and Deliberative Democracy. Clinical Medicine 5(5): 471–475.

    Rawlins M. D. , 'Phamacopolitics and Deliberative Democracy ' (2005 ) 5 Clinical Medicine : 471 -475.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Reykowski, J. (2006): Deliberative Democracy and “Human Nature”: An empirical approach. Political Psychology 27(3): 323–346.

    Reykowski J. , 'Deliberative Democracy and “Human Nature”: An empirical approach ' (2006 ) 27 Political Psychology : 323 -346.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Rittel, H. — Webber, M. (1973): Dilemmas in General Theory of Planning. Policy Sciences 4(2): 155–169.

    Webber M. , 'Dilemmas in General Theory of Planning ' (1973 ) 4 Policy Sciences : 155 -169.

  • Rowe, G. — Frewer, L. J. (2000): Public Participation Methods: A framework for evaluation. Science Technology & Human Values 25(3): 3–29.

    Frewer L. J. , 'Public Participation Methods: A framework for evaluation ' (2000 ) 25 Science Technology & Human Values : 3 -29.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Sanders, L. M. (1997): Against Deliberation. Political Theory 25(3): 347–376.

    Sanders L. M. , 'Against Deliberation ' (1997 ) 25 Political Theory : 347 -376.

  • Scutchfield, F. D. — Hall, L. — Ireson, C. L. (2006): The Public and Public Health Organizations: Issues for community engagement in public policy. Health Policy 77: 76–85.

    Ireson C. L. , 'The Public and Public Health Organizations: Issues for community engagement in public policy ' (2006 ) 77 Health Policy : 76 -85.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Sólyom, L. (2008): Statement by President László Sólyom on returning the ‘Act on the health insurance managed funds...’, 27. December 2007. In: Mihályi, P., ed.: Health Insurance Reform in Hungary, Volume 2. Rise and fall , Budapest: Europe Ltd.

    Sólyom L. , '', in Health Insurance Reform in Hungary, Volume 2. Rise and fall , (2008 ) -.

  • Szócska, M. K. — Réthelyi, J. M. — Normand, C. (2005): Managing Healthcare Reform in Hungary: Challenges and Opportunities. British Medical Journal 331: 231–233.

    Normand C. , 'Managing Healthcare Reform in Hungary: Challenges and Opportunities ' (2005 ) 331 British Medical Journal : 231 -233.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Svensson, J. (2008): It’s Long Way form Helsingborg to Porto Alegre: A case study in deliberative democracy in late modernity. Journal of Public Deliberation 4(1).

  • Vartiainen, P. (2005): Wicked Health Care Issues: An analysis of Finnish and Swedish health care reforms. Advances in Health Care Management: International Health Care Management 5: 163–186.

    Vartiainen P. , 'Wicked Health Care Issues: An analysis of Finnish and Swedish health care reforms ' (2005 ) 5 Advances in Health Care Management: International Health Care Management : 163 -186.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Wagenaar, H. (2007): Governance, Complexity, and Democratic Participation: How Citizens and Public Officials Harness the Complexities of Neighborhood Decline. The American Review of Public Administration 37(1): 17–50.

    Wagenaar H. , 'Governance, Complexity, and Democratic Participation: How Citizens and Public Officials Harness the Complexities of Neighborhood Decline ' (2007 ) 37 The American Review of Public Administration : 17 -50.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Yankelovich, D. (1995): The Debate that Wasn’t: The Public and the Clinton Plan. Health Affairs 14(1): 7–23.

    Yankelovich D. , 'The Debate that Wasn’t: The Public and the Clinton Plan ' (1995 ) 14 Health Affairs : 7 -23.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Zimmerman, B. — Lindberg, C. — Plsek, P. (2001): Edgeware: Insights form Complexity Science for Health Care Leaders . Irving, TX: VHA Inc.

    Plsek P. , '', in Edgeware: Insights form Complexity Science for Health Care Leaders , (2001 ) -.

    • Search Google Scholar