Author: Zsolt Darvas
View More View Less
  • 1 Corvinus University of Budapest Department of Mathematical Budapest Hungary
  • 2 Bruegel Brussels Belgium
  • 3 Centre for Economic and Regional Studies of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences Budapest Hungary
Restricted access

Data from 135 countries covering five decades suggest that creditless recoveries, in which the stock of real credit does not return to the pre-crisis level for three years after the GDP trough, are not rare and are characterised by remarkable real GDP growth rates: 4.7 percent per year in middle-income countries and 3.2 percent per year in high-income countries. However, the implications of these historical episodes for the current European situation are limited, for two main reasons. First, creditless recoveries are much less common in high-income countries than in low-income countries which are financially undeveloped. European economies heavily depend on bank loans and research suggests that loan supply played a major role in the recent weak credit performance of Europe. There are reasons to believe that, despite various efforts, normal lending has not yet been restored. Limited loan supply could be disruptive for the European economic recovery and there has been only a minor substitution of bank loans with debt securities. Second, creditless recoveries were associated with significant real exchange rate depreciation, which has hardly occurred so far in most of Europe. This stylised fact suggests that it might be difficult to re-establish economic growth in the absence of sizeable real exchange rate depreciation, if credit growth does not return.

  • Abiad A. — Dell’Ariccia G. — Li B. (2011): Credit-less Recoveries. IMF Working Paper 11/58.

    Li B. , 'Credit-less Recoveries ' (2011 ) 11 IMF Working Paper : 58 -.

  • Adrian T. — Colla P. — Shin H. S. (2012): Which Financial Frictions? Parsing the Evidence from the Financial Crisis of 2007-9. NBER Working Paper 18335.

    Shin H. S. , '', in NBER Working Paper , (2012 ) -.

  • Aiyar S. (2011): How Did the Crisis in International Funding Markets Affect Bank Lending? Balance Sheet Evidence from the United Kingdom. Bank of England Working Paper 424.

    Aiyar S. , '', in Bank of England Working Paper , (2011 ) -.

  • Allard J. — Balvy R. (2011): Market Phoenixes and Banking Ducks: Are Recoveries Faster in Market-based Economies? IMF Working Paper 11/213.

    Balvy R. , 'Market Phoenixes and Banking Ducks: Are Recoveries Faster in Market-based Economies ' (2011 ) 11 IMF Working Paper : 213 -.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Basel Committee (2013): Basel Committee Releases Revised Version of Basel III’s Liquidity Coverage Ratio’, Press Release, Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, 7 January, http://www.bis.org/press/p10107.htm , accessed 3 March 2014

    '', in Basel Committee Releases Revised Version of Basel III’s Liquidity Coverage Ratio’ , (2013 ) -.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Bayoumi T. — Lee J. — Jayanthi S. (2006): New Rates from New Weights. IMF Staff Papers 53(2): 272–305.

    Jayanthi S. , 'New Rates from New Weights ' (2006 ) 53 IMF Staff Papers : 272 -305.

  • Becker B. — Ivashina V. (2011): Cyclicality of Credit Supply: Firm Level Evidence. NBER Working Paper 17392.

    Ivashina V. , '', in NBER Working Paper , (2011 ) -.

  • Bernanke B. — Gertler M. — Gilchrist S. (1996): The Financial Accelerator and the Flight to Quality. Review of Economics and Statistics 78(1): 1–15.

    Gilchrist S. , 'The Financial Accelerator and the Flight to Quality ' (1996 ) 78 Review of Economics and Statistics : 1 -15.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Biggs M. — Mayer T. — Pick A. (2009): Credit and Economic Recovery. De Nederlandsche Bank Working Paper 218/2009.

    Pick A. , 'Credit and Economic Recovery ' (2009 ) 218 De Nederlandsche Bank Working Paper : 2009 -.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Bijlsma M. — Zwart G. T. J. (2013): The Changing Landscape of Financial Markets in Europe, the United States and Japan. Bruegel Working Paper 2013/02.

    Zwart G. T. J. , '', in Bruegel Working Paper , (2013 ) -.

  • Bijsterbosch M. — Dahlhaus T. (2011): Determinants of Credit-less Recoveries. European Central Bank Working Paper 1358.

    Dahlhaus T. , '', in European Central Bank Working Paper , (2011 ) -.

  • Braun M. — Larrain B. (2005): Finance and the Business Cycle: International, Inter-industry Evidence. The Journal of Finance 60(3): 1097–1128.

    Larrain B. , 'Finance and the Business Cycle: International, Inter-industry Evidence ' (2005 ) 60 The Journal of Finance : 1097 -1128.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Calvo G. A. — Izquierdo A. — Talvi E. (2006a): Phoenix Miracles in Emerging Markets: Recovering without Credit from Systemic Financial Crises. NBER Working Paper 12101.

    Talvi E. , '', in NBER Working Paper , (2006 ) -.

  • Calvo G. A. — Izquierdo A. — Talvi E. (2006b): Sudden Stops and Phoenix Miracles in Emerging Markets. American Economic Review 96(2): 405–410.

    Talvi E. , 'Sudden Stops and Phoenix Miracles in Emerging Markets ' (2006 ) 96 American Economic Review : 405 -410.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Claessens S. — Kose M. A. — Terrones M. E. (2009a): A recovery without credit: Possible, but..., 22 May, voxeu.org.

    Terrones M. E. , '', in A recovery without credit: Possible, but... , (2009 ) -.

  • Claessens S. — Kose M. A. — Terrones M. E. (2009b): What Happens during Recessions, Crunches and Busts? Economic Policy 24(60): 653–700.

    Terrones M. E. , 'What Happens during Recessions, Crunches and Busts ' (2009 ) 24 Economic Policy : 653 -700.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Darvas Z. (2012a): Real Effective Exchange Rates for 178 Countries: A New Database. Bruegel Working Paper 2012/06.

    Darvas Z. , '', in Bruegel Working Paper , (2012 ) -.

  • Darvas Z. (2012b): Compositional Effects on Productivity, Labour Cost and Export Adjustment. Bruegel Policy Contribution 2012/11.

    Darvas Z. , '', in Bruegel Policy Contribution , (2012 ) -.

  • Darvas Z. (2013): Banking System Soundness is the Key to More SME Financing. Bruegel Policy Contribution 2013/10.

    Darvas Z. , '', in Bruegel Policy Contribution , (2013 ) -.

  • Del Giovane P. — Eramo G. — Nobili A. (2012): Disentangling Demand and Supply in Credit Developments: ASurvey-based Analysis for Italy. Journal of Banking & Finance 35: 2719–2732.

    Nobili A. , 'Disentangling Demand and Supply in Credit Developments: ASurvey-based Analysis for Italy ' (2012 ) 35 Journal of Banking & Finance : 2719 -2732.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Gertler M. (2013): Comment on “Which Financial Frictions? Parsing the Evidence from the Financial Crisis of 2007 to 2009”. In: Acemoglu D. — Parker J. — Woodford M. (eds): NBER Macroeconomics Annual 2012, 27: 215–223.

    Gertler M. , 'Comment on “Which Financial Frictions? Parsing the Evidence from the Financial Crisis of 2007 to 2009” ' (2013 ) 27 NBER Macroeconomics Annual 2012 : 215 -223.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Gilchrist S. — Zakrajsek E. (2012): Credit Spreads and Business Cycle Fluctuations. American Economic Review 102(4): 1692–1720.

    Zakrajsek E. , 'Credit Spreads and Business Cycle Fluctuations ' (2012 ) 102 American Economic Review : 1692 -1720.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Gill I. — Raiser M. and others (2012): Golden Growth: Restoring the Lustre of European Economic Model. Washington DC: World Bank.

  • Hempell H.S. — Kok Sørensen C. (2010): The Impact of Supply Constraints on Bank Lending in the Euro Area: Crisis Induced Crunching? European Central Bank Working Paper 1262.

    Kok Sørensen C. , '', in European Central Bank Working Paper , (2010 ) -.

  • Hodrick R. — Prescott E.C. (1997): Postwar U.S. Business Cycles: An Empirical Investigation. Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 29(1): 1–16.

    Prescott E.C. , 'Postwar U.S. Business Cycles: An Empirical Investigation ' (1997 ) 29 Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking : 1 -16.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Hristov N. — Hülsewig O. — Wollmershäuser T. (2012): Loan Supply Shocks during the Financial Crisis: Evidence for the Euro Area. Journal of International Money and Finance 31: 569–592.

    Wollmershäuser T. , 'Loan Supply Shocks during the Financial Crisis: Evidence for the Euro Area ' (2012 ) 31 Journal of International Money and Finance : 569 -592.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • International Monetary Fund (2009): World Economic Outlook. Washingotn DC: IMF.

    '', in World Economic Outlook , (2009 ) -.

  • Jiménez G. — Ongena S. — Peydró J.-L. — Saurina J. (2012): Credit Supply versus Demand: Bank and Firm Balance-Sheet Channels in Good and Crisis Times. European Banking Center Discussion Paper 2012-003.

    Saurina J. , '', in European Banking Center Discussion Paper , (2012 ) -.

  • OECD (2012): Financing SMEs and Entrepreneurs 2012: An OECD Scoreboard. Paris: OECD.

    '', in Financing SMEs and Entrepreneurs 2012: An OECD Scoreboard , (2012 ) -.

  • OECD (2013): Strengthening Euro Area banks, http://www.oecd.org/eco/economicoutlookanalysisandforecasts/strengtheningeuroareabanks.htm , accessed 5 March 2014

    '', in Strengthening Euro Area banks , (2013 ) -.

  • Ravn M.O. — Uhlig H. (2002): On Adjusting the Hodrick-Prescott Filter for the Frequency of Observations. The Review of Economics and Statistics 84(2): 371–375.

    Uhlig H. , 'On Adjusting the Hodrick-Prescott Filter for the Frequency of Observations ' (2002 ) 84 The Review of Economics and Statistics : 371 -375.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Veugelers R. (2011): Assessing the Potential for Knowledge-based Development in Transition Countries. Society and Economy 33(3): 475–504.

    Veugelers R. , 'Assessing the Potential for Knowledge-based Development in Transition Countries ' (2011 ) 33 Society and Economy : 475 -504.

    • Search Google Scholar
  • Wolff G.B. (2012): Arithmetic is Absolute: Euro Area Adjustment. Bruegel Policy Contribution 2012/09.

    Wolff G.B. , '', in Bruegel Policy Contribution , (2012 ) -.