There is general consensus that the field of nanotechnology will be very important in the future. An open question is, however,
which technological approaches or paradigms will be important in the field. The paper assumes that the carbon nanotube will
be a key element of an emerging technological paradigm in nanotechnology. This study employs a bibliometric method — bibliographic
coupling — to identify important nanotubes-related ‘leitbilder’ — a concept meaning ‘guiding images’ that provide a basis
for different professions and disciplines to work in the same direction. Until recently, bibliographic coupling has been applied
rarely for purposes of research evaluation, not to mention technology foresight. Our case study seems to suggest that bibliographic
coupling is particularly suitable for anticipating technological breakthroughs. Bibliographic coupling analysis of recent
nanotube-related patents focused our attention to recent patents owned by Nantero Inc. Nantero’s main focus is the development
of NRAM — a high-density nonvolatile random access memory. The NRAM leitbild seems to be an important emerging leitbild. It
connects technical opportunities and promising applications relating to the memories in devices such as cell phones, MP3 players,
digital cameras, as well as applications in networking arena.
Authors:Mu-Hsuan Huang, Li-Yun Chiang, and Dar-Zen Chen
This paper uses bibliographic coupling analysis to plot out a patent citation map. It explores the current research and development
in the high-tech electronic companies in Taiwan, and the relationship between companies and industries. Fifty-eight high-tech
electronic companies under this study, between 1998 and 2000, obtained 4162 patents from U.S., and cited 24,852 patents during
these years. Through the data from bibliographic coupling analysis, the paper categorizes these companies into 6 major groups:
semiconductor, peripheral, scanners, notebook / monitor, system, IC design / packaging. This research also uses multidimensional
scaling to plot out a patent citation map, graphically displaying the association among the groups. The result shows a higher
similarity among companies in semiconductor sector, whereas the distinction between industries grows more and more ambivalent,
even overlapping in some cases.
In this article we study directed, acyclic graphs. We introduce the head and tail order relations and study some of their
properties. Recalling the notions of generalized bibliographic coupling and generalized co-citation, and introducing a new
property, called the l - property, we come to a characterization of lattices. As document citation networks are concrete realizations of directed
acyclic graphs all our results are directly applicable to citation analysis.
In an earlier study the authors have shown that bibliographic coupling techniques can be used to identify hot research topics. The methodology is based on appropriate thresholds for both number of related documentsand the strength of bibliographic links. Those papers are calledcore documents that have more than 9 links of at least the strength 0.25 according toSalton's measure, provided they are articles, notes or reviews. This choice resulted in a selection of nearly one per cent of all papers of the above types recorded in the 1992 annual cumulation of the SCI.Core documents proved important nodes in the network of documented science communication.In the present study, the set ofcore documents is analysed by journals, subfields and corporate addresses. The latter analysis is conducted on both national and regional-institutional level. First all countries which have published at least 20 core documents in 1992 are investigated in terms of their research profiles, their international collaboration patterns and their citation impact. Finally, those eight members of the European Union which have published at least 20 core documents in 1992 are analysed in respect of regional and institutional distribution of core documents.
Scientometric analysis of the cognitive-epistemological structure of science is traditionally based whether on citation links (e.g., bibliographiccoupling, cross-citation, co-citation analysis) and textual links
This paper deals with two document-document similarity approaches in the context of science mapping: bibliographic coupling
and a text approach based on the number of common abstract stems. We used 43 articles, published in the journal Information Retrieval, as test articles. An information retrieval expert performed a classification of these articles. We used the cosine measure
for normalization, and the complete linkage method was used for clustering the articles. A number of articles pairs were ranked
(1) according to descending normalized coupling strength, and (2) according to descending normalized frequency of common abstract
stems. The degree of agreement between the two obtained rankings was low, as measured by Kendall’s tau. The agreement between
the two cluster solutions, one for each approach, was fairly low, according to the adjusted Rand index. However, there were
examples of perfect agreement between the coupling solution and the stems solution. The classification generated by the expert
contained larger groups compared to the coupling and stems solutions, and the agreement between the two solutions and the
classification was not high. According to the adjusted Rand index, though, the stems solution was a better approximation of
the classification than the coupling solution. With respect to cluster quality, the overall Silhouette value was slightly
higher for the stems solution. Examples of homogeneous cluster structures, as well as negative Silhouette values, were found
with regard to both solutions. The expert classification indicates that the field of information retrieval, as represented
by one volume of articles published in Information Retrieval, is fairly heterogeneous regarding research themes, since the classification is associated with 15 themes. The complete linkage
method, in combination with the upper tail rule, gave rise to a fairly good approximation of the classification with respect
to the number of identified groups, especially in case of the stems approach.
analysis if each of the components causes specific problems in the application to long-term analysis. The inappropriateness of the application of both bibliographiccoupling and co-citation analysis over periods, say, longer than 10 years are caused by
comprising stemmed words. The matrix was subjected to a network analysis for clusters and mapping aided by visualization with VOSviewer (Van Eck and Waltman 2010 ). (iii) Analysis for bibliographiccoupling of items in terms of journals in cited references
between documents in the dataset under study can be based on the number of shared (significant) words, or on the number of shared cited references (bibliographiccoupling), or on a combination of these two numbers, or on direct citations.
. Price ( 1965 ) introduced the concept of research fronts based on citations and Kessler ( 1963 ) bibliographiccoupling of publications sharing references in 1973 co-citation was introduced by Small and Marshakova. Chen and Morris ( 2003 ) identified