Inserting citations to authorities into a text, in order to increase the persuasive power of it, and prove the competence of the author, has a long tradition in science and in law. The question is whether this also applies to judicial decisions. This question is especially interesting in a continental legal culture, where following previous cases is not obligatory, there is no stare decisis, and therefore, inserting a reference to a previous case may have a different function. In 2012 we performed a computer-based citation analysis of the court decisions published under FOI act on the official website of the National Office for the Judiciary (Országos Bírósági Hivatal). The article contains four sections. The first and the second sections are dealing with citations within judicial decisions in general, and their significance in different legal cultures. The third section is about the quantitative, while the fourth is about the qualitative part of the research, and tackle the issue whether citations increase the quality of judicial reasoning or not. The answer will be limited to the Hungarian legal culture.
Austin, J. M. , ‘The Law of Citations and Seriatim Opinions: Were the Ancient Romans and the Early Supreme Court on the Right Track?’ (2010) 31 Northern Illinois University Law Review 19–36.
Bast, C. M. , ‘What’s in a Name? Shepard’s Citators’ (1998) 14 Journal of Paralegal Education and Practice 41–58.
Beniger, J. R. , The Control Revolution (Harvard University Press 1986).
Cross, F. B., Spriggs II, J. F., Timothy, R. J. and Wahlbeck, P. J., ‘Citations in the U.S Supreme Court: An Empirical Study of their Use, and Significance 2010’ (2010) University of Illinois Law Review 489–576.
Friedman, L. M., Kagan, R. A., Cartwright, B. and Wheeler, S., ‘State Supreme Courts: A Century of Style and Citation’ (1981) 33 Stanford Law Review 773–818.
Garfield, E. , ‘Citation Indexes to Science: A New Dimension in Documentation through Association of Ideas’ (1955) 122 Science 108–111.
Goutal, J. L. , ‘Characteristics of Judicial Style in France, Britain and the U.S.A.’ (1976) 24 American Journal of Comparative Law (1976) 43–72.
Johnson, C. A. , ‘Citations to Authority in Supreme Court Opinions’ (1985) 7 Law & Policy 509–523.
Landes, W. A. and Posner, R. A., ‘Legal Precendent: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis’ (1976) 19 Journal of Law&Economy 249–308.
McCormick, P. , ‘Judicial Citation, the Supreme Court of Canada and the Lower Courts: The Case of Alberta’ (1996) 34 Alberta Law Review 870–891.
Merryman, J. H. , ‘The Authority of Authority: What the California Supreme Court Cited in 1950’ (1953–1954) 6 Stanford Law Review 613–673.
Merryman, J. H. , ‘Toward a Theory of Citations: An Emprical Study of the Citation Practice of the California Supreme Court in 1950, 1960, and 1970.’ (1977–1978) 50 Southern California Law Review 381–396.
Smyth R. , ‘An Empirical Study of Citation Practice in the New Zeeland Court of Appeal’ (2000) 31 Victoria University Wellington Law Review 847–895.
Wagner-Döbler, R. and Lothar, P., ‘Präjudizien in der Rechtsprechung: Statistische Untersuchungenanhand der Zitierpraxisdeutscher Gerichte’ (1992) 23 Rechtsteorie 228–242.
Watson, A. , Law out of Context (University of Georgia Press 2000).
West, J. B. ‘The Multiplicity of Reports’ (1909–1910) 2 Law Library Journal 15–45.