Move is subject to phase-based locality, whereas Agree is not, a natural consequence of cyclic linearization. Then, null operator movement, having no impact on linearization, should be immune to certain phase-related effects. I show that this prediction is borne out, based on the interactions between (null operator) movement and ellipsis. Furthermore, I extend the present proposal to scrambling in Japanese. It turns out that the observed correlation between movement and ellipsis helps us choose among competing theories of scrambling. Specifically, theoretical as well as empirical considerations support an analysis of scrambling in Japanese as involving either null operator movement or PF movement.
Authier, J.-Marc P . 1989. Two types of empty operator. Linguistic Inquiry 20. 117–125.
Bailyn, John Frederick . 2001. On scrambling: A reply to boškovic and takahashi. Linguistic Inquiry 22. 635–658.
Boškovic, Željko . 2007a. Agree, phases, and intervention effects. Linguistic Analysis 33. 54–96.
Boškovic, Željko . 2007b. On the locality and motivation of Move and Agree: An even more minimal theory. Linguistic Inquiry 38. 589–644.
Boškovic, Željko and Daiko Takahashi. 1998. Scrambling and last resort. Linguistic Inquiry 29. 347–366.
Browning, Marguerite Ann . 1987. Null operator constructions. Doctoral dissertation. MIT. (Published by Garland, New York, in 1991.).
Chomsky, Noam . 1977. On wh-movement. In P. W. Culicover, T. Wasow and A. Akmajian (eds.) Formal syntax. New York: Academic Press. 71–132.
Chomsky, Noam . 1993. A minimalist program for linguistic theory. In K. Hale and S. J. Keyser (eds.) The view from building 20. Essays in linguistics in honor of Sylvain Bromberger. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. 1–52.
Chomsky, Noam . 1995. The minimalist program. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Chomsky, Noam . 2001. Derivation by phase. In Kenstowicz (2001, 1–52).
Chomsky, Noam . 2008. On phases. In R. Freidin, C. P. Otero and M. L. Zubizarreta (eds.) Foundational issues in linguistic theory. Essays in honor of Jean-Roger Vergnaud. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. 134–166.
Chung, Sandra, William A. Ladusaw and James McCloskey. 1995. Sluicing and logical form. Natural Language Semantics 3. 239–282.
Dikken, Marcel den . 2007. Phase extension: Contours of a theory of the role of head movement in phrasal extraction. Theoretical Linguistics 33. 1–41.
Enç, Mürvet . 1987. Anchoring conditions for tense. Linguistic Inquiry 18. 633–658.
Epstein, Samuel David and T. Daniel Seely. 2006. Derivations in Minimalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Fox, Danny and David Pesetsky. 2005. Cyclic linearization of syntactic structure. Theoretical Linguistics 31. 1–54.
Gallego, Ángel J . 2007. Phase theory and parametric variation. Doctoral dissertation. UAB.
Holmberg, Anders . 2001. The syntax of yes and no in Finnish. Studia Linguistica 55. 141–175.
Huang, Cheng-Teh James . 1993. Reconstruction and structure of VP. Linguistic Inquiry 24. 103–138.
Kenstowicz, Michael (ed.). 2001. Ken Hale: A life in language. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Kuroda, Shige-Yuki . 1988. Whether we agree or not: A comparative syntax of English and Japanese. In W. J. Poser (ed.) Papers from the Second International Workshop on Japanese Syntax. Stanford: CSLI Publications. 103–143.
Lasnik, Howard and Tim Stowell. 1991. Weakest crossover. Linguistic Inquiry 22. 687–720.
Lecarme, Jacqueline . 2004. Tense in nominals. In J. Guéron and J. Lecarme (eds.) The syntax of time. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. 440–475.
Manzini, M. Rita . 2000. Sentential complementation: The subjunctive. In P. Coopmans, M. Everaert and J. Grimshaw (eds.) Lexical specification and insertion. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins. 241–268.
May, Robert . 1977. The grammar of quantification. Doctoral dissertation. MIT.
Merchant, Jason . 2001. The syntax of silence. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Merchant, Jason . 2008. An asymmetry in voice mismatches in VP-ellipsis and pseudogapping. Linguistic Inquiry 39. 169–179.
Miyagawa, Shigeru . 2003. A-movement scrambling and options without optionality. In S. Karimi (ed.) Word order and scrambling. Malden, MA & Oxford: Blackwell. 177–200.
Nakamura, Masanori . 2009. The Ellipsis Movement Generalization and the notion of phase. In K. K. Grohmann (ed.) InterPhases: Phase-theoretic investigations of linguistic interfaces. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 317–338.
Oku, Satoshi . 1998. A theory of selection and reconstruction in the Minimalist perspective. Doctoral dissertation. University of Connecticut, Storrs.
Pesetsky, David and Esther Torrego. 2001. T-to-C movement: Causes and consequences. In Kenstowicz (2001, 355–427).
Postal, Paul . 1971. Cross-over phenomena. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
Potts, Christopher . 2002. The syntax and semantics of as-parentheticals. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 20. 623–689.
Rizzi, Luigi . 2004. Locality and left periphery. In A. Belletti (ed.) Structures and beyond: The cartography of syntactic structures 3. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 223–251.
Saito, Mamoru . 1985. Some asymmetries in Japanese and their theoretical implications. Doctoral dissertation. MIT.
Saito, Mamoru . 1992. Long distance scrambling in Japanese. Journal of East Asian Linguistics 1. 69–118.
Saito, Mamoru . 2003. A derivational approach to the interpretation of scrambling chains. Lingua 113. 481–518.
Sauerland, Uli and Paul Elbourne. 2002. Total reconstruction, PF movement and derivational order. Linguistic Inquiry 33. 283–319.
Stowell, Tim . 1986. Null antecedents and proper government. In S. Berman, J.-W. Choe and J. McDonough (eds.) Proceedings of the North East Linguistic Society (NELS) 16. Amherst, MA: University of Massachusetts, GLSA. 476–493.
Takahashi, Daiko . 2008. Quantificational null objects and argument ellipsis. Linguistic Inquiry 39. 307–326.
Tanaka, Hidekazu . 2008. Clausal complement ellipsis. Manuscript. University of York.
Uchibori, Asako . 1997. Opacity and subjunctive complements in Japanese. In H. min Sohn and J. Haig (eds.) Japanese/Korean Linguistics 6. Stanford: CSLI Publications. 399–414.
Uchibori, Asako . 2000. The syntax of subjunctive complements: Evidence from Japanese. Doctoral dissertation. University of Connecticut.
Ueyama, Ayumi . 1998. Two types of dependency. Doctoral dissertation. University of Southern California.
Ueyama, Ayumi . 2003. Two types of scrambling constructions in Japanese. In A. Barss (ed.) Anaphora: A reference guide. Malden, MA & Oxford: Blackwell. 23–71.
Wasow, Thomas . 1972. Anaphoric relations in English. Doctoral dissertation. MIT.