Of course, university departments have wider responsibilities than research (Coronini and Mangematin 1999).
A search on Shapley in abstracts of papers published in Scientometrics returns nothing.
A search on HHI in abstracts of papers published in Scientometrics returned one paper on research performance (Yang et al. 2010).
de Witte and Rogge (2010) introduce a metric for publication efficiency which combines individual and environmental characteristics.
Note that in the definition of the Shapley value actors are not evaluated relative to an existing coalition structure. This is another reason why the proposed measure is a pseudo-Shapley value.
This is intuitively clear, but notationally messy. I therefore skip the formalization. The computations are illustrated in the “Appendix” section.
I therefore refer to the indicators S, P, and M as cardinal pseudo-Shapley values.
There are also a number of business schools that only teach. These are excluded from the current study.
Note that the database contains another 124 individuals who were erroneously included.
For instance, Publish and Perish returns over 500 papers for the current author, whose CV counts less than 200 publications.
I am grateful to all who helped to improve the database by checking their entries. I had useful discussions on this subject with Frances Ruane. An anonymous referee had excellent comments.
Coronini, R, Mangematin, V 1999 From individual scientific visibility to collective competencies: The example of an academic department in the social sciences. Scientometrics 45 1 55–80 .
Cox, RAK, Chung, KH 1991 Patterns of research output and author concentration in the economics literature. Review of Economics and Statistics 73 4 740–747 .
Crewe, I 1988 Reputation, research and reality: The publication records of UK departments of politics, 1978–1984. Scientometrics 14 3–4 235–250 .
d’Aspremont, C, Jacquemin, A, Gabszewicz, JJ, Weymark, JA 1983 On the stability of collusive price leadership. Canadian Journal of Economics 16 1 17–25 .
K de Witte Rogge, N 2010 To publish or not to publish? On the aggregation and drivers of research performance. Scientometrics 85 3 657–680 .
Harzing, A-W 2005 Australian research output in economics and business: High output, low impact?. Australian Journal of Management 30 2 183–200 .
Harzing, A-W 2010 The publish or perish book—Tour guide to effective and responsible citation analysis Tarma Software Research Melbourne.
Hirsch, JE 2005 An index to quantify an individual's scientific research output. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 102:16569–16572 .
Hodder, APW, Hodder, C 2010 Research culture and New Zealand's performance-based research fund: Some insights from bibliographic compilations of research outputs. Scientometrics 84 3 887–901 .
Kalaitzidakis, P, Mamuneas, TP, Stengos, T 2003 Rankings of academic journals and institutions in economics. Journal of the European Economic Association 1 6 1346–1366 .
Kao, C, Pao, HL 2009 An evaluation of research performance in management of 168 Taiwan universities. Scientometrics 78 2 261–277 .
Lee, GJ 2010 Assessing publication performance of research units: Extensions through operational research and economic techniques. Scientometrics 84 3 717–734 .
Mingers, J, Lipitakis, EAEC 2010 Counting the citations: A comparison of Web of Science and Google Scholar in the field of business and management. Scientometrics 85 2 613–625 .
Nederhof, AJ 2008 Policy impact of bibliometric rankings of research performance of departments and individuals in economics. Scientometrics 74 1 163–174 .
Nederhof, AJ, Noyons, ECM 1992 Assessment of the international standing of university departments’ research: A comparison of bibliometric methods. Scientometrics 24 3 393–404 .
Rubin, RM, Chang, CF 2003 A bibliometric analysis of health economics articles in the economics literature: 1991–2000. Health Economics 12 5 403–414 .
Shapley, LS 1953 A value for n-person games HW Kuhn AW Tucker eds. Contributions to the theory of games, volume II 28 Princeton University Press Princeton 307–317.
Tol, R. S. J. (2010). The research output of business schools and business scholars in Ireland. Working Paper 364, Economic and Social Research Institute, Dublin.
Vieira, ES, Gomes, JANF 2009 A comparison of Scopus and Web of science for a typical university. Scientometrics 81 2 587–600 .
Vieira, PC, Teixeira, AAC 2010 Are finance, management, and marketing autonomous fields of scientific research? An analysis based on journal citations. Scientometrics 85 3 627–646 .
Yang, S, Ma, F, Song, Y, Qiu, J 2010 A longitudinal analysis of citation distribution breadth for Chinese scholars. Scientometrics 85 3 755–765 .